EN
Shipping and Logistics

How to Measure Carrier Performance: On-Time Delivery, Damage and Loss, Undeliverable Shipments, Effective Cost per Shipment and Shipment Reallocation Training

How do you measure carrier performance? On-time delivery, damage and loss, return rate and effective cost per shipment: an 8-lesson guide with examples.

Contents 14 sections
  1. What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
  2. Lesson 1: Why is the shipping fee alone not a sufficient measure?
  3. Lesson 2: What are the three core indicators?
  4. Lesson 3: How do you build a carrier comparison table?
  5. Lesson 4: How do you determine the unit cost of problems?
  6. Lesson 5: How do you calculate the effective cost per shipment?
  7. Lesson 6: What is the effect of reallocating shipments?
  8. Lesson 7: How do you set up a shipping rule by region and product?
  9. Lesson 8: How do you monitor carrier performance?
  10. What are the most common mistakes when measuring shipping performance?
  11. How does NetKasam make shipping performance tracking easier?
  12. Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
  13. Conclusion: Choose your carrier by its real cost, not its fee
  14. Frequently Asked Questions About Carrier Performance

When choosing a carrier, most businesses look at price first: the work goes to whichever one has the lowest fee per shipment. Yet the fee is only one part of a shipment's real cost. A package delivered late puts a burden on customer service, a damaged or lost package means reshipment and lost product, and a package that cannot be delivered to the address makes you pay the shipping fee twice. Measuring carrier performance means putting these hidden costs into a per-shipment figure and comparing carriers by their real costs.

This article is not a narrative but an 8-lesson practical training. We will answer the question how to measure carrier performance using an example business that ships 3,000 packages a month with three carriers: the three core indicators (on-time delivery, damage and loss, undeliverable shipments), the carrier comparison table, the unit cost of problems, the effective cost per shipment, the effect of reallocating shipments, setting rules by region and product, and monitoring indicators. At the end there is a mini quiz and an answer key. All figures are example values chosen to demonstrate the method; carrier names are referred to generically as A, B and C, so follow the same steps with your own data.

What will you be able to do by the end of this training?

In short: You will measure carriers with three indicators, calculate the monetary cost of problems, find the effective cost per shipment and reallocate shipment shares according to cost.

Training mapSix steps to measuring carrier performance
  1. 01
    CollectGet shipment, delivery, damage and return data by carrier.
  2. 02
    RateCalculate the three indicators for each carrier.
  3. 03
    PriceDetermine the unit cost of problems.
  4. 04
    CostFind the effective cost per shipment.
  5. 05
    AllocateReset shipment shares according to cost.
  6. 06
    MonitorTrack the indicators monthly and give feedback to the carrier.

The 8 lessons of the training: (1) why the fee is not a sufficient measure, (2) the three core indicators, (3) the carrier comparison table, (4) the unit cost of problems, (5) the effective cost per shipment, (6) the effect of reallocating shipments, (7) rules by region and product, (8) monitoring indicators.

Lesson 1: Why is the shipping fee alone not a sufficient measure?

In short: The fee is only what you pay. Late delivery, damage and failed delivery are costs added on top of the fee that do not show up when you check the invoice.

The items on a shipping invoice are the fee, additional services and desi (volumetric weight) differences; you check the invoice's accuracy with the method in the article how to check a shipping invoice. But that invoice does not show whether the package reached the customer, when it arrived or whether it arrived damaged. This information sits in order and tracking records and has to be brought together in a separate exercise.

The second reason to measure performance is negotiation. When you show the carrier your shipment volume and problem rate in figures, you have data for discussions about a price discount, compensation periods or service level. The third reason is customer experience: delivery is the most visible step in how customers evaluate you. For ways to inform customers about every step of their order, see the article how to send order notifications to customers.

Lesson 2: What are the three core indicators?

In short: The on-time delivery rate, the damage and loss rate and the undeliverable shipment rate. Each shows a different problem.

FormulaThe three indicators of carrier performance and effective cost
  1. On-time delivery rate = Shipments delivered within the promised time ÷ Total shipments
  2. Damage and loss rate = Damaged or lost shipments ÷ Total shipments
  3. Undeliverable rate = Shipments that could not be delivered to the address and were returned ÷ Total shipments
  4. Effective cost = (Shipping fee + Total cost of problems) ÷ Number of shipments

The definition of "on time" should be written down: the time the carrier commits to (for example next day, two business days) or the delivery time you tell the customer is the basis. The day the shipment is picked up should also be clear: it counts as the day the carrier picks up the package, not the day you prepare it. To measure order preparation time separately, see the article how to measure and shorten time to handover to the carrier. We explained how to keep damage and loss records in the article how to track lost and damaged shipments.

Lesson 3: How do you build a carrier comparison table?

In short: For each carrier, write the number of shipments, the three rates and the unit fee side by side.

The example business splits 3,000 shipments a month among three carriers:

CarrierShipmentOn-time deliveryDamage and lossUndeliverableUnit fee
A1.500%95,0 (1.425)%1,0 (15)%3,0 (45)62 ₺
B900%90,0 (810)%2,0 (18)%4,0 (36)55 ₺
C600%78,0 (468)%4,0 (24)%7,0 (42)48 ₺
Total3.000%90,1 (2.703)%1,9 (57)%4,1 (123)
ChartOn-time delivery rate: the cheapest carrier is the one that delivers latest
  1. Carrier A (₺62)95.0%
  2. Carrier B (₺55)90.0%
  3. Carrier C (₺48)78.0%

Prepared with example values. Rate: shipments delivered on time ÷ total shipments.

Total on-time deliveries are 1,425 + 810 + 468 = 2,703 shipments; 2,703 ÷ 3,000 = 90.1%. Damage and loss is 15 + 18 + 24 = 57 shipments (1.9%), and undeliverable is 45 + 36 + 42 = 123 shipments (4.1%). In the table, fee and performance move in opposite directions: as the fee falls, the on-time delivery rate falls and the damage and return rates rise. Do not forget regional differences; a carrier may be strong in certain regions and weak in others. To set rules by region, see the article how to create a region-based shipping rule.

Lesson 4: How do you determine the unit cost of problems?

In short: Set a unit cost for each type of problem: late delivery, damage and loss, and undeliverable shipments.

ProblemUnit costWhat does it include?
Late delivery40 ₺Customer service work, inquiries, compensation discounts and a share of return risk
Damage or loss350 ₺The part of the product cost the carrier does not cover, reshipment, packaging and labor
Undeliverable shipment90 ₺Return shipping fee, reshipment and management labor

These unit costs are example assumptions; calculate them for your own business from your records. The cost of late delivery is the average of the "where is my package" calls to customer service and, where applicable, the discounts or refunds given. The cost of damage and loss is the difference between the product's purchase cost and the compensation received from the carrier; read from the contract under what conditions compensation is paid. For an undeliverable shipment, both the outbound and the return fee are paid. For the total cost of the return and send-back process, see the article how to calculate return cost, and for how to take returned products back into inventory, see the article how to put a returned product back into inventory.

Lesson 5: How do you calculate the effective cost per shipment?

In short: Effective cost is found by adding the cost of problems to the shipping fee and dividing by the number of shipments. In the example, A is ₺70.20, B is ₺69.60 and C is ₺77.10.

ItemCarrier ACarrier BCarrier C
Shipping fee (shipments × unit fee)1.500 × 62 = 93.000 ₺900 × 55 = 49.500 ₺600 × 48 = 28.800 ₺
Late delivery (number × ₺40)75 × 40 = 3.000 ₺90 × 40 = 3.600 ₺132 × 40 = 5.280 ₺
Damage and loss (number × ₺350)15 × 350 = 5.250 ₺18 × 350 = 6.300 ₺24 × 350 = 8.400 ₺
Undeliverable (number × ₺90)45 × 90 = 4.050 ₺36 × 90 = 3.240 ₺42 × 90 = 3.780 ₺
Total cost105.300 ₺62.640 ₺46.260 ₺
Effective cost per shipment70,20 ₺69,60 ₺77,10 ₺

Late delivery counts are found by subtracting on-time deliveries from shipments: for A 1,500 − 1,425 = 75, for B 900 − 810 = 90, for C 600 − 468 = 132. Total costs: for A 93,000 + 3,000 + 5,250 + 4,050 = ₺105,300; for B 49,500 + 3,600 + 6,300 + 3,240 = ₺62,640; for C 28,800 + 5,280 + 8,400 + 3,780 = ₺46,260. Per shipment: 105,300 ÷ 1,500 = 70.20; 62,640 ÷ 900 = 69.60; 46,260 ÷ 600 = ₺77.10.

ChartEffective cost per shipment: the carrier with the lowest fee turns out the most expensive
  1. Carrier A (fee ₺62)₺70.20
  2. Carrier B (fee ₺55)₺69.60
  3. Carrier C (fee ₺48)₺77.10

Prepared with example values. Effective cost: (fee + cost of problems) ÷ shipments.

The ranking has changed: the fee ranking is C, B, A, while the effective cost ranking is B, A, C. At C, a problem cost of ₺29.10 (5,280 + 8,400 + 3,780 = 17,460 ÷ 600) is added to the ₺48 fee per shipment; at A, that addition is only ₺8.20 (12,300 ÷ 1,500). So C's fee advantage of ₺14 is lost as it turns into ₺20.90 in problem cost. To read the fee difference correctly, also verify the desi (volumetric weight) and weight calculation; the article how to calculate desi is for that. We explained that packaging size affects both damage and the fee in the article how to calculate and reduce packaging cost.

Lesson 6: What is the effect of reallocating shipments?

In short: Moving half of C's 600 shipments to A and B saves ₺4,320 per month if service levels do not change.

Let 300 of C's 600 shipments be moved to A and 300 to B. At A, 300 shipments at an effective cost of ₺70.20 come to ₺21,060; at B, 300 shipments at ₺69.60 come to ₺20,880. At C, the cost of these shipments is ₺46,260. After the move, the cost falls to 21,060 + 20,880 = ₺41,940.

ChartMonthly result of moving C's shipments to A and B: ₺4,320 saved
  1. Monthly cost of 600 shipments at C₺46,260
  2. Cost of the 300 shipments moved to A−₺21,060
  3. Cost of the 300 shipments moved to B−₺20,880
  4. Monthly savings₺4,320

Prepared with example values. Total: 46,260 − 21,060 − 20,880 = ₺4,320.

The annual savings are 4,320 × 12 = ₺51,840. But this calculation rests on two assumptions: that A and B can carry the extra volume at the same service level, and that C's shipments are not made up of hard-to-reach regions. That is why the move is made gradually: first 100 shipments are moved, and performance is measured again a month later. Before changing the shipment share you give carriers, check the contract terms (volume discount, minimum shipment commitment): the carrier whose share you reduce may take back a discount. For how carrier integration works and how to choose a carrier, see the article how carrier integration works and how to choose one.

Lesson 7: How do you set up a shipping rule by region and product?

In short: Carriers do not perform the same in every region. Set up a rule that distributes shipments among carriers by region, desi (volumetric weight) and product value.

  1. By region: Measure carrier performance by province or region; make the carrier with the lowest effective cost the default for each region.
  2. By product value: Route valuable or fragile products to the carrier with a low damage rate, and low-value, durable products to the cheap carrier.
  3. By desi: Compare carriers' desi-based fee differences and route light and heavy packages to different carriers.
  4. Backup carrier: Set up a second carrier for each region; when the first has a disruption, shipments do not stop.
  5. Free shipping threshold: For orders above the threshold, the business bears the shipping cost; include the effective cost in this calculation (how to set a free shipping threshold).

The rule works consistently if it is set up so that distribution among carriers is done by the system rather than by hand. Choosing the most suitable carrier by region, province, district or customer can be done from the order screen; for details, see the article how to create a region-based shipping rule. The speed at which an order is handed to the carrier is also part of performance measurement: if preparation is delayed, the on-time delivery rate falls without the carrier being at fault; to plan the workload in the warehouse, see the article how to plan warehouse workload.

Recommended ReadingHow to Track Lost and Damaged Shipments

Lesson 8: How do you monitor carrier performance?

In short: Monitor five indicators monthly: on-time delivery rate, damage and loss rate, undeliverable rate, effective cost per shipment and shipment share by carrier.

IndicatorHow it is calculatedExample value (total)
On-time delivery rateOn-time deliveries ÷ Shipments%90,1
Damage and loss rateDamaged or lost ÷ Shipments%1,9
Undeliverable rateReturned ÷ Shipments%4,1
Effective cost(Fee + cost of problems) ÷ Shipments71,40 ₺
Carrier shareShipments given to the carrier ÷ Total shipmentsA 50%, B 30%, C 20%

The total effective cost is (105,300 + 62,640 + 46,260) ÷ 3,000 = 214,200 ÷ 3,000 = ₺71.40. After the move, the total cost becomes 214,200 − 4,320 = ₺209,880, and falls to ₺69.96 per shipment.

Takeaways from the exampleThe four numbers of the carrier performance example
  • 78%on-time delivery rate of the cheapest carrier
  • ₺77.10effective cost per shipment of the carrier whose fee is ₺48
  • ₺69.60lowest effective cost (fee ₺55)
  • ₺4,320monthly savings from moving C's shipments

In monitoring, the direction of the indicators matters more than a single month's value. If a carrier's on-time delivery rate falls two months in a row, a volume increase, a new region or an operational problem is investigated. During holidays and campaign periods all carriers slow down; evaluate these periods separately. Before peak periods, ask carriers for an additional capacity commitment; for preparation, see the article how to prepare for a busy campaign period. To take the report to a management meeting, a shipping line can be added to the layout in the article how to prepare a weekly management report.

Recommended readingHow Do You Route Orders Across Multiple Warehouses? A Course on Shipping Cost Matrix, Cheapest Warehouse Rule, Stock Constraints, Order Split Cost and Warehouse Transfers

What are the most common mistakes when measuring shipping performance?

  1. Looking only at the fee. A carrier that looks cheap can be the most expensive once its problems are counted.
  2. Taking the wrong delivery date. Preparation delays get blamed on the carrier, or the reverse.
  3. Not recording damage and loss. The compensation period passes and the cost stays with the business.
  4. Not comparing carriers in the same region. A carrier's load of hard-to-reach regions makes its performance look worse than it is.
  5. Changing the shipment share all at once. The new carrier's capacity is not tested, and the service level drops.
  6. Not setting up a backup carrier. When one carrier has a disruption, all shipments stop.
  7. Not sharing the data with the carrier. Negotiation on discounts and service levels is not based on data.

How does NetKasam make collection tracking easier?

  • One click from order to carrier. You send your orders to the carrier, create the barcode and pass tracking information to the customer (shipping integration).
  • Seeing shipping costs. You manage your shipping costs with full visibility from A to Z.
  • Regional management. With region, province, district or customer-based definitions, you ensure the most suitable carrier is selected.
  • Status tracking and sharing. You monitor shipping status and share the tracking link via WhatsApp, SMS or email.
  • Fast bulk processing. You hand your orders to the carrier in bulk (order management).
  • Saved reports. You save the monthly report and export it to Excel (reports).
  • Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.

Mini quiz: Test what you have learned

In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.

  1. If 468 of 600 shipments were delivered on time, what is the on-time delivery rate in percent?
  2. How many shipments were not delivered on time, and if the cost of late delivery is ₺40, what is the total amount?
  3. If there are 600 shipments and the unit fee is ₺48, what is the total shipping fee?
  4. If the total cost is ₺46,260 and the number of shipments is 600, how many ₺ is the effective cost per shipment?
  5. If a cost of ₺46,260 falls to ₺41,940, what are the monthly savings?

Answer key:

  1. 468 ÷ 600 = %78.
  2. 600 − 468 = 132 shipments; 132 × 40 = ₺5,280.
  3. 600 × 48 = 28.800 ₺.
  4. 46.260 ÷ 600 = 77,10 ₺.
  5. 46.260 − 41.940 = 4.320 ₺.

Frequently Asked Questions About Carrier Performance

How do you measure carrier performance?

You calculate the on-time delivery rate, the damage and loss rate and the undeliverable shipment rate; then you add the cost of these problems to the shipping fee to find the effective cost per shipment.

Is the cheapest carrier always the best?

No. If a low-fee carrier has high rates of late delivery, damage and returns, the cost of those problems can outweigh the fee advantage. In the example, the cheapest carrier turns out to be the most expensive per shipment.

How is on-time delivery defined?

As the number of shipments delivered within the committed time, or the time you told the customer, counted from the day the carrier picks up the package. The definition should be written down.

How is the cost of problems calculated?

You set a separate unit cost for late delivery, damage and loss, and undeliverable shipments, and multiply each by the number of cases of that type. Unit costs are derived from your own records.

How should I change the shipment share?

Gradually. First shift a small portion, then measure performance again a month later. Check the volume discount and commitment terms in the contract beforehand.

Is it necessary to choose carriers by region?

Yes. Carriers do not perform the same in every region; it is better to measure by region and make the carrier with the lowest effective cost the default for each region.

Why do I need a backup carrier?

So that shipments do not stop when one carrier has a disruption. Setting up a second carrier for each region ensures continuity.

How often should carrier performance be monitored?

Monthly. Holiday and campaign periods are evaluated separately, and the on-time delivery rate can also be tracked weekly.

Conclusion: Choose your carrier by its real cost, not its fee

The most useful thing you can do today is to split the last month's shipments by carrier and calculate on-time delivery, damage and return rates. The next step is to set the unit cost of problems, work out the effective cost per shipment and gradually reduce the share of the most expensive carrier. If the fee ranking and the effective cost ranking come out different, the savings opportunity lies exactly in that difference.

Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free

Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.

Start FreeShipping Integration

Read similar articles

19 free tools

Commission, shipping, VAT and profit calculations in your browser, no sign-up needed.

All tools