How Do You Track Lost and Damaged Shipments? A Guide to Incident Cost, the Claims Process, the Insurance Decision, Comparing Carriers and Incident Logs
How do you track lost and damaged shipments? Incident cost, claim evidence, the insurance decision, carrier comparison and monitoring: an 8-lesson guide with examples.
Contents 14 sections
- What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
- Lesson 1: Why should lost and damaged shipments be tracked separately?
- Lesson 2: What is the real cost of a lost or damaged shipment?
- Lesson 3: How do you file a compensation claim, and what evidence is needed?
- Lesson 4: How much does compensation recover, and how can it be improved?
- Lesson 5: When does shipping insurance make sense?
- Lesson 6: How do you compare carriers together with their incident rates?
- Lesson 7: How are incidents recorded?
- Lesson 8: How do you monitor losses and damage?
- What are the most common mistakes in tracking lost and damaged shipments?
- How does NetKasam make tracking lost and damaged shipments easier?
- Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
- Conclusion: Gather this month's loss and damage incidents in a single table
- Frequently Asked Questions About Lost and Damaged Shipments
On Monday morning a customer writes: "My order shows as shipped, but it hasn't arrived in three weeks." You prepared that order, packed it and paid for shipping; and the product got lost in transit. You have to send the customer a new product, but the cost is not just the product itself: on top of that come a second shipment, a second packing job and the time spent with the customer. And whether you can get compensation from the carrier depends on whether you gathered the evidence that day.
This article is not an overview but an 8-lesson hands-on training. We will answer the question how do you track lost and damaged shipments using an e-commerce business that sends 3,000 shipments a month: the real cost of an incident, what evidence is needed in the claim process, the recovery rate, when shipping insurance makes sense, comparing two carriers together with their incident rates, the incident record layout and monitoring indicators. At the end there is a mini quiz and an answer key. You can find the price check on shipping invoices in the article how to check a shipping invoice; this article is not about price but about shipments that are lost or damaged.
What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
In short: You will calculate the cost of an incident, file compensation claims with evidence, make insurance and carrier decisions based on numbers, and track incidents on record.
- 01IncidentRecord its type and date.
- 02CostCalculate the real cost of the incident.
- 03EvidencePrepare a complete claim file.
- 04InsuranceCompare the premium with the additional compensation.
- 05CarrierEvaluate the fee together with the incident rate.
- 06MonitoringTrack the incident rate and recovery.
The training's 8 lessons: (1) incident types and why they should be tracked, (2) the real cost of an incident, (3) compensation claims and evidence, (4) recovery and improvement, (5) the insurance decision, (6) carrier comparison, (7) incident record layout, (8) monitoring indicators.
Lesson 1: Why should lost and damaged shipments be tracked separately?
In short: Losses and damage don't show up like normal returns; they stay scattered in the records, which is why their real cost is unknown at most businesses. Tracking them separately both protects your right to compensation and shows which carrier or which packing setup is causing problems.
| Incident type | What happens | First step |
|---|---|---|
| Lost | The shipment never arrives; tracking stops progressing | Official loss notification to the carrier |
| Damaged | The shipment arrives but the product is damaged | Photos and a report at the time of delivery |
| Missing contents | The package arrives, but a product or some units inside are missing | Footage of the package being opened and a weight record |
| Shown as delivered but not received | Tracking says "delivered," but the customer says they didn't receive it | Request the delivery signature and location information |
The first two types are the most common; the third and fourth are harder to resolve because they are usually noticed later. In this training we will use a common calculation method because all four types have a similar cost structure: the product and shipping are paid for again, and time is lost.
Sample business: an e-commerce business that sends about 3,000 shipments a month, with an average order value of ₺450, product cost of ₺300, shipping cost of ₺55 and packing cost of ₺10. There are 36 incidents during the month: 24 lost, 12 damaged. So the incident rate is 1.2%. This rate looks small, but as you will see below, each incident costs more than the price of the product.
Lesson 2: What is the real cost of a lost or damaged shipment?
In short: The incident cost is found by adding the shipping, packing and support costs of the reshipment to the product cost. The sale price received from the customer does not count as a gain in this calculation, because money was spent a second time to get the product to the customer.
- Incident cost = Product cost + Reshipment shipping + Repacking + Support cost
- Gross monthly cost = Number of incidents × Incident cost
- Net loss = Gross monthly cost − Compensation received
Prepared with sample values.
| Item | Amount | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Product cost | 300 ₺ | The product that was lost or became unusable |
| Reshipment shipping | 55 ₺ | Second shipment to the customer |
| Repacking | 10 ₺ | Box, tape, label and labor |
| Support cost | 20 ₺ | Time spent corresponding with the customer and following up with the carrier |
| Incident cost | 385 ₺ | 300 + 55 + 10 + 20 |
Let's look at why the calculation does not include the shipping and packing cost of the first shipment: that expense would have been incurred even without the incident; it was part of the normal cost of sale. The additional cost caused by the incident is the spending on the reshipment plus the product itself. So while an order's normal contribution is 450 − 300 − 55 − 10 = ₺85, when an incident occurs the order closes at 85 − 385 = −₺300. In other words, a single loss wipes out the contribution of four and a half new orders at the same profit margin (385 ÷ 85 ≈ 4.5).
Monthly total: 36 incidents × ₺385 = ₺13,860. Although it looks like a small share next to the monthly order contribution (3,000 shipments × ₺85 = ₺255,000), this amount adds up to ₺166,320 a year and is usually scattered among expense items without anyone noticing. We covered return-related costs separately in the article how to calculate return costs; losses and damage are the shipping-side equivalent of the same logic.
Lesson 3: How do you file a compensation claim, and what evidence is needed?
In short: Compensation depends on the evidence gathered at the time of the incident and the deadline in your shipping contract. Claims with a complete tracking number, product value, photos and delivery information are accepted at a much higher rate.
| Incident type | Required evidence | Common gaps |
|---|---|---|
| Lost | Tracking number, shipment date, product invoice value, loss notification | Reporting late |
| Damaged | Photos of the outside and inside of the package, a photo of the damaged product, delivery date | Throwing the package away without taking photos |
| Missing contents | Package weight record, opening footage, order contents | Not recording the shipment weight |
| Shown as delivered but not received | Tracking record, customer statement, request for the delivery signature | Not requesting the signature and location information |
The claim deadline and the scope of compensation vary according to your shipping contract; so read the deadline and amount conditions in your contract, and use the following assumptions for a sample calculation: the loss or damage notification must be made within a certain period after shipment, and the amount paid depends on the product's invoice value and the cap in the contract. In this training, the average compensation paid is taken as ₺350 (sample condition).
Delaying the claim has two costs. First, the deadline in the contract may pass and the claim is rejected. Second, the evidence disappears: the package is thrown away, no photos are taken, the customer correspondence gets scattered. That is why the first thing the person who notices the incident should do is open an incident record and start an evidence folder. To inform the customer, you can use the templates in the article how to send order notifications to customers.
Recommended ReadingHow Do You Check a Shipping Invoice?Lesson 4: How much does compensation recover, and how can it be improved?
In short: The difference between the gross incident cost and the compensation received is the net loss. There are two levers that shrink the net loss: getting rejected claims accepted with evidence and preventing avoidable incidents in the first place.
For example, claims were filed for 30 of the 36 incidents; for 6, no claim could be filed at all because the deadline passed or no evidence could be found. 21 claims were accepted and 9 were rejected.
- Compensation accepted₺2158.3%
- Claim rejected₺925%
- No claim could be filed₺616.7%
Prepared with sample values.
| Group | Incidents | Net cost per incident | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compensated | 21 | 35 ₺ (385 − 350) | 735 ₺ |
| Uncompensated | 15 | 385 ₺ | 5.775 ₺ |
| Total net loss | 36 | – | 6.510 ₺ |
Check: gross cost 36 × 385 = ₺13,860; compensation received 21 × 350 = ₺7,350; net loss 13,860 − 7,350 = ₺6,510, that is, 47% of the gross cost. The recovery rate is 7,350 ÷ 13,860 = 53.0%. The claim rate is 30 ÷ 36 = 83.3%, and the acceptance rate is 21 ÷ 30 = 70%.
The improvement scenario rests on two assumptions. First lever: with an evidence standard, 6 of the 15 rejected or unfiled incidents are accepted; each drops from ₺385 to ₺35, a saving of 6 × 350 = ₺2,100. Second lever: 4 incidents caused by wrong or incomplete addresses and weak packaging are prevented in the first place; since these are among the uncompensated incidents, the saving is the full incident cost, 4 × 385 = ₺1,540.
- Current monthly net loss₺6,510
- 6 additional claims accepted with an evidence standard−₺2,100
- 4 incidents prevented with address checks and packaging−₺1,540
- Improved monthly net loss₺2,870
Prepared with sample values. Total: 6,510 − 2,100 − 1,540 = ₺2,870.
Check: in the improved scenario, 27 incidents close with compensation (27 × 35 = ₺945), 5 incidents stay uncompensated (5 × 385 = ₺1,925) and 4 incidents never happen; total 945 + 1,925 = ₺2,870. In other words, two small adjustments cut the net loss by about 56%, and no investment is needed for this. To reduce problems caused by wrong addresses, checking the address and phone number before packing the order is enough; for checks to make during packing, see the article how to do order picking and packing.
Lesson 5: When does shipping insurance make sense?
In short: Insurance or a declared value is profitable when the premium paid is less than the amount it recovers on incidents that would otherwise go uncompensated. The measure is the premium per shipment.
Insurance's contribution in the example: if all 15 uncompensated incidents had received ₺350 in compensation under insurance, the additional recovery would have been 15 × 350 = ₺5,250. For 3,000 shipments a month, the break-even premium is 5,250 ÷ 3,000 = ₺1.75.
| Premium per shipment | Monthly premium | Additional compensation | Net effect | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1,00 ₺ | 3.000 ₺ | 5.250 ₺ | +2.250 ₺ | Profitable |
| 1,75 ₺ | 5.250 ₺ | 5.250 ₺ | 0 | Break-even |
| 3,00 ₺ | 9.000 ₺ | 5.250 ₺ | −3.750 ₺ | Loss-making |
Insuring every shipment is usually expensive, because most incidents are already the kind for which compensation can be obtained, and the premium is paid on all 3,000 shipments. A more sensible approach is selective insurance on high-value products: as product value rises, incident cost rises too, and while the premium per shipment is proportional to product value, the cost of going uncompensated grows faster than the premium. For low-value products, accepting the incident as a risk instead of paying the premium usually comes out cheaper.
When making the insurance decision, also read what the contract covers: damaged products, missing contents and shipments "shown as delivered but not received" may be excluded. Paying a premium and then having an excluded incident is the worst outcome. To see the cost per shipment together with desi and region, see how to calculate desi and the shipping fee calculator.
Lesson 6: How do you compare carriers together with their incident rates?
In short: A carrier's real cost is the shipment fee plus the incident rate multiplied by the incident cost. A carrier with a low fee but a high incident rate can turn out more expensive overall.
The 3,000 monthly shipments are split between two carriers: 2,000 shipments to Carrier A and 1,000 to Carrier B. Carrier A's fee is ₺55 and Carrier B's is ₺49. Incidents: 12 at A, 24 at B (36 in total).
| Carrier | Shipment | Incidents | Incident rate | Fee | Incident share | Total cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carrier A | 2.000 | 12 | %0,6 | 55,00 ₺ | 2,31 ₺ (0,006 × 385) | 57,31 ₺ |
| Carrier B | 1.000 | 24 | %2,4 | 49,00 ₺ | 9,24 ₺ (0,024 × 385) | 58,24 ₺ |
- Carrier A (fee + incident share)₺57.31
- Carrier B (fee + incident share)₺58.24
Prepared with sample values. The incident share was calculated with the gross incident cost, before deducting compensation.
Carrier B looks ₺6 cheaper in fees, but carries 9.24 − 2.31 = ₺6.93 more incident share on every shipment. B's break-even incident rate: from the equation 55 + 2.31 = 57.31 = 49 + x × 385, x = 8.31 ÷ 385 = 2.16%. In other words, if B's incident rate had stayed below 2.16%, it would have been cheaper than A overall; at 2.4%, it is not.
We made this comparison without deducting compensation, because the claim process differs from carrier to carrier, and the amount payable on paper is often not the same as the amount actually received. A more conservative calculation uses the gross incident cost. If you make the comparison by region, you get an even clearer result: a carrier may be strong in certain regions and weak in others; for this logic, see the article how to create region-based shipping rules, and for integration and carrier selection, see the article how shipping integration works and how to choose one.
Lesson 7: How are incidents recorded?
In short: Each incident is kept on a single line: order, tracking number, type, evidence, claim, outcome and the solution given to the customer. The record feeds both the claim process and the monthly analysis.
| Area | Example | Why it's needed |
|---|---|---|
| Order no. and tracking no. | Order number, tracking code | The first information requested in a claim |
| Type | Lost, damaged, missing contents | Evidence differs by type |
| Carrier and region | Carrier A, province | For carrier and region comparison |
| Date noticed | Day | To track the claim deadline |
| Evidence status | Complete / incomplete | Explains the acceptance rate |
| Claim and outcome | Date, accepted / rejected, amount | Calculates the recovery |
| Customer solution | Reshipment / refund | Determines the inventory and invoice records |
The background records also change depending on the solution given to the customer. If a reshipment is made, the first product is deducted from inventory and a new shipment is opened for the second product; if a refund is made, the order is cancelled and the invoice is corrected. For these steps, follow the flow in the articles how to cancel an order and how to issue a return invoice. Deducting the lost product from inventory creates an inventory discrepancy; close it by writing down the reason, as described in the article how to find and close inventory discrepancies. For the accounting entry of the compensation, consult your certified public accountant.
In NetKasam, you can track marketplace and e-commerce orders on a single screen, update order statuses, and cancel or partially cancel them when needed. Orders ready to ship are sent to the carrier through the shipping integration, and the shipping information is passed to the sales platform; with filters, you can list orders with incidents in bulk. For details, see the pages order management and shipping integration.
Lesson 8: How do you monitor losses and damage?
In short: Track six indicators monthly: incident rate, net cost per incident, claim rate, acceptance rate, recovery rate and average resolution time. If one deteriorates, the root cause is investigated.
| Indicator | Sample value | How it is calculated |
|---|---|---|
| Incident rate | %1,2 | Incidents ÷ Shipments (36 ÷ 3,000) |
| Net cost per incident | ≈181 ₺ | Net loss ÷ Incidents (6,510 ÷ 36) |
| Claim rate | %83,3 | Claims filed ÷ Incidents (30 ÷ 36) |
| Acceptance rate | %70 | Accepted ÷ Claims filed (21 ÷ 30) |
| Recovery rate | %53,0 | Compensation received ÷ Gross cost (7,350 ÷ 13,860) |
| Average resolution time | From your own records | Days from noticing the incident to compensation payment |
- ₺385real cost of a single incident
- 53%of gross cost recovered through compensation
- ₺2,870monthly net loss achievable with improvements (down from ₺6,510)
- 2.16%incident rate at which Carrier B would break even with A
If the incident rate is rising, first look at the breakdown by carrier and region; incidents concentrated on a single route are a reason to talk to the carrier. If the acceptance rate is low, there is missing evidence or delay; if the claim rate is low, incidents are slipping through the process. If the recovery rate is low while the incident rate holds steady, the compensation terms in the shipping contract need to be reviewed. To do the monthly tracking together with other operational indicators, see the article how to prepare a weekly management report.
Recommended readingHow to Manage Orders in E-Commerce?What are the most common mistakes in tracking lost and damaged shipments?
- Counting only the product price as the cost. Reshipment, packing and support time are forgotten.
- Delaying the claim. The deadline in the contract passes and the evidence disappears.
- Not gathering evidence. Without photos, weight records and delivery information, the claim is rejected.
- Confusing incidents with returns. If incidents are not tracked separately, carrier-specific problems stay invisible.
- Choosing a carrier on fee alone. The incident rate changes the total cost.
- Insuring every shipment. The premium is often greater than the compensation gained.
- Not correcting the inventory record. The lost product keeps showing as inventory in the system.
How does NetKasam make tracking lost and damaged shipments easier?
- Single-screen order management. You see marketplace and e-commerce orders together, update their statuses, and cancel or partially cancel them (order management).
- Shipping integration. Orders ready to ship are sent to the carrier automatically and you pass the shipping information to the sales platform; you can work with more than one carrier at the same time (shipping integration).
- Filters and bulk actions. You filter orders, update their statuses in bulk and list orders with incidents together.
- Inventory movements report. You see the inventory deduction of the lost product and the inventory discrepancy on record (inventory management).
- Saved reports. You export the incident list to Excel and track the breakdown by carrier and region in your own spreadsheet (reports).
- Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.
Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.
- If the product cost is ₺200, reshipment shipping is ₺50, packing is ₺8 and support cost is ₺12, what is the incident cost?
- Claims were filed for 15 of 20 incidents, and 9 were accepted. What are the claim rate and the acceptance rate?
- The incident cost is ₺270, the average compensation is ₺250, and 9 incidents were accepted. What are the gross cost, the compensation received and the recovery rate?
- Insurance would bring ₺3,000 in additional compensation, and there are 2,000 shipments a month. What is the break-even premium per shipment?
- Carrier A: fee ₺40, incident rate 1%; Carrier B: fee ₺36, incident rate 2.5%. If the incident cost is ₺270, which one is cheaper?
Answer key:
- 200 + 50 + 8 + 12 = 270 ₺.
- Claim rate 15 ÷ 20 = 75%; acceptance rate 9 ÷ 15 = 60%.
- Gross cost 20 × 270 = ₺5,400; compensation received 9 × 250 = ₺2,250; recovery 2,250 ÷ 5,400 = 41.7%.
- 3.000 ÷ 2.000 = 1,50 ₺.
- A: 40 + 0.01 × 270 = ₺42.70; B: 36 + 0.025 × 270 = ₺42.75. A is slightly cheaper; since the difference is only ₺0.05, at this point monitoring the incident rate and whether the carrier's performance changes becomes decisive.
Frequently Asked Questions About Lost and Damaged Shipments
How do you track lost and damaged shipments?
You record each incident on a single line with the order, tracking number, type, evidence, claim and outcome, and monitor the incident rate, acceptance rate and recovery monthly.
How do you calculate the cost of a lost shipment?
Product cost, reshipment shipping, repacking and support cost are added up; if compensation is received, the net loss is found by deducting it from this amount.
What evidence is needed for a compensation claim?
The tracking number, shipment date, product invoice value and, depending on the type of incident, photos, a package weight record or delivery information. The deadline and coverage vary according to your shipping contract.
What should I do with a damaged shipment?
Before throwing the package away, take photos of the outside and inside, note the delivery date and report the damage to the carrier within the deadline.
Should I get shipping insurance?
You should if the premium per shipment is lower than the amount the insurance recovers on incidents that would otherwise go uncompensated. For most businesses, selective insurance, meaning insurance only on high-value products, makes more sense.
What criterion should I use to choose a carrier?
The shipment fee plus the incident rate multiplied by the incident cost; a carrier with a low fee can turn out more expensive overall if its incident rate is high.
Should I reship to the customer or issue a refund?
It depends on the customer's preference and your inventory. With a reshipment, the first product is deducted from inventory; with a refund, the order is cancelled and the invoice is corrected.
How does NetKasam help with tracking losses and damage?
It manages orders on a single screen, transfers shipments through the shipping integration, lists orders with incidents using filters and bulk actions, and provides inventory movements and saved reports; bookkeeping is free.
Conclusion: Gather this month's loss and damage incidents in a single table
The most useful thing you can do today is gather last month's lost, damaged and missing-contents shipments in a single table. Write the incident cost on each line, and add whether a claim was filed and its outcome. When you see the total, two things become clear: the carriers' incident rates and the loss in the claim process. The next step is to standardize the evidence folder and address checks; as in the example, these two adjustments can cut the net loss by more than half.
Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free
Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.