How to Create a Region-Based Shipping Rule: Carrier Comparison, Cheapest Option, Quality Threshold and Customer Exception Training
How do you create a region-based shipping rule? Carrier comparison, choosing the cheapest, a quality threshold and customer exceptions: an 8-lesson practical guide with examples.
Contents 14 sections
- What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
- Lesson 1: Why do you need a shipping rule?
- Lesson 2: How do you compare carriers by region?
- Lesson 3: How much does choosing the cheapest carrier save?
- Lesson 4: Which criteria besides price go into the rule?
- Lesson 5: Which types of rules can be defined?
- Lesson 6: What preparations are made before setting up the rule?
- Lesson 7: What does a customer exception cost?
- Lesson 8: How do you review the shipping rule monthly?
- What are the most common mistakes in region-based shipping rules?
- How does NetKasam make shipping rules easier?
- Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
- Conclusion: Break down your latest shipping invoice by region this month
- Frequently Asked Questions About Region-Based Shipping Rules
You have agreements with two carriers. One is cheap in Marmara, the other offers better prices to the East, but out of habit all orders are transferred to a single carrier. At month end you look at the shipping invoice: shipments to some regions cost more than necessary, and a customer complained because their order was not sent with the carrier they wanted. The problem is not the carriers; it is the lack of a rule that decides which order goes with which carrier. A shipping rule writes this decision once, before the order, by region, size and customer.
This article is not just an explanation; it is an 8-lesson practical course. We will answer how to create a region-based shipping rule with numbers using a sample business that ships 1,200 packages a month and works with two carriers: region-based comparison of carriers, the calculation for choosing the cheapest, non-price criteria, rule types, preparations, the cost of customer exceptions and the monthly review. At the end there is a mini quiz and an answer key. For the general setup of a shipping integration, see the article how shipping integration works and how to choose one; here we set up the multi-carrier rule.
What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
In short: You will compare carriers' region-based prices, calculate the financial impact of choosing the cheapest, add non-price criteria to the rule, see the cost of customer exceptions and review the shipping rule monthly.
- 01DataPull the number of shipments by region.
- 02PriceCompare carriers' regional prices.
- 03CriteriaAdd non-price criteria.
- 04RuleWrite region, size and customer rules.
- 05TestTest the rule with a few orders.
- 06MonitoringReview monthly cost and complaints.
The 8 lessons of the course: (1) why you need a shipping rule, (2) region-based price comparison, (3) the calculation for choosing the cheapest, (4) non-price criteria, (5) rule types, (6) preparations, (7) the cost of customer exceptions, (8) the monthly review.
Lesson 1: Why do you need a shipping rule?
In short: If you work with more than one carrier and which carrier each order goes with is not tied to a rule, the decision is made out of habit. Habit is often the most expensive choice.
| Without a rule | With a rule |
|---|---|
| Orders always go to the same carrier | The carrier suited to the region is chosen |
| If the customer's request is forgotten, a complaint arises | A customer-specific carrier is defined |
| Cost is seen when the invoice arrives | The rule determines cost in advance |
| Each shipment is routed manually | The order is transferred automatically |
In NetKasam, you can work with all integrated carriers at the same time. When you define rules by region, province, district or customer, the system selects the carrier deemed suitable for the delivery region and transfers the order automatically. This method is used to avoid shipping more expensively to a region. For details, see the shipping integration page. Sample business: an e-commerce seller shipping 1,200 packages a month with agreements with two carriers.
Lesson 2: How do you compare carriers by region?
In short: First pull the regional distribution of your shipments, then put each carrier's price for that region side by side. The comparison is made not with average prices but with region-weighted prices.
| Region | Monthly shipments | Carrier A price | Carrier B price | Cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marmara | 480 | 58 ₺ | 64 ₺ | A |
| Central Anatolia | 210 | 70 ₺ | 66 ₺ | B |
| Aegean | 180 | 66 ₺ | 61 ₺ | B |
| Mediterranean | 130 | 72 ₺ | 69 ₺ | B |
| East and Southeast | 110 | 86 ₺ | 79 ₺ | B |
| Black Sea | 90 | 78 ₺ | 72 ₺ | B |
| Total | 1.200 |
Prices are sample values chosen only to illustrate the calculation; actual prices depend on your agreement with the carrier, desi (volumetric weight) and seasonal increases. If you look at average prices, A's average is ₺66.88 and B's is ₺66.42, and the difference looks insignificant. When you look by region, however, you see that A is advantageous only in Marmara, while B is cheaper in the other five regions.
- Marmara480 shipments
- Central Anatolia210 shipments
- Aegean180 shipments
- Mediterranean130 shipments
- East and Southeast110 shipments
- Black Sea90 shipments
Prepared with sample values. Marmara is 40% of the total (480 ÷ 1,200).
Lesson 3: How much does choosing the cheapest carrier save?
In short: Cost with the rule = the sum, across all regions, of each region's shipments × the lowest price in that region. The difference from using a single carrier is the financial value of the rule.
- Single-carrier cost = Σ (Regional shipments × Carrier price)
- Cost with the rule = Σ (Regional shipments × Lowest price)
- Saving = Single-carrier cost − Cost with the rule
- Cost per shipment = Total cost ÷ Number of shipments
Prepared with sample values.
| Region | All A | All B | With the rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marmara | 27.840 ₺ | 30.720 ₺ | 27.840 ₺ |
| Central Anatolia | 14.700 ₺ | 13.860 ₺ | 13.860 ₺ |
| Aegean | 11.880 ₺ | 10.980 ₺ | 10.980 ₺ |
| Mediterranean | 9.360 ₺ | 8.970 ₺ | 8.970 ₺ |
| East and Southeast | 9.460 ₺ | 8.690 ₺ | 8.690 ₺ |
| Black Sea | 7.020 ₺ | 6.480 ₺ | 6.480 ₺ |
| Total | 80.260 ₺ | 79.700 ₺ | 76.820 ₺ |
- All shipments with carrier A₺80,260
- Moving the Aegean to B−₺900
- Moving Central Anatolia to B−₺840
- Moving the Mediterranean to B−₺390
- Moving the Black Sea to B−₺540
- Moving the East and Southeast to B−₺770
- Cost with the region rule₺76,820
Prepared with sample values. Total saving ₺3,440 (4.3%); ₺64.02 per shipment instead of ₺66.88.
On a yearly basis, the saving comes to 3,440 × 12 = ₺41,280. This figure may not look high, but the cost of setting up the rule once is very low, and the saving grows as the number of shipments increases. For the effect of shipping costs on profit, see the article how to calculate net profit on a marketplace.
Lesson 4: Which criteria besides price go into the rule?
In short: The cheapest carrier is not always the best carrier. Delivery time, damage and loss rates and returns handling can change the choice if the price difference is small.
| Criterion | Why does it matter? | How is it measured? |
|---|---|---|
| Delivery time | Late delivery brings complaints and returns | Average days from shipment to delivery |
| Damage and loss | Compensation process and customer loss | Monthly rate of damaged shipments |
| Returns and reverse shipping | Return shipping is an extra cost | Number of return shipments |
| Customer communication | Tracking information reduces complaints | Number of tracking inquiries |
In the example, B is ₺7 cheaper in the East region (₺79 versus ₺86), but if B's delay rate in that region is twice A's, the ₺770 saving on 110 shipments may have been eaten up by delay complaints and returns. That is why the rule looks at price first and then at a quality threshold: if a carrier exceeds a certain delay or damage rate, it is removed from that region. For the cost of damaged and returned shipments, see the article how to calculate the cost of returns. The article how to check a shipping invoice complements this on checking desi and rates on invoices.
Lesson 5: Which types of rules can be defined?
In short: In NetKasam, rules can be defined by region, province, district, price, size or customer. Shipments brought into the system via Excel or manual entry are also included in the same tracking flow.
| Rule | What happens? | Example use |
|---|---|---|
| Region / province / district | The carrier suited to the region is selected | Eastern provinces to B |
| Price and size | Rules are set for the carrier based on price and size | Large-desi products to the carrier with a suitable rate |
| Customer | The customer's preferred carrier is assigned | A wholesale customer wants their own carrier |
| Excel / manual | Shipments are imported into the system by file or manually | Shipments outside the panel |
So that rules do not conflict with each other, clarify priority during setup: a customer-specific rule should generally come before size and region rules, so that if a customer wants a specific carrier, the region rule does not override it. Confirm which rule takes priority with a few test shipments. For desi and size calculation, see the article how to calculate desi.
Lesson 6: What preparations are made before setting up the rule?
In short: You make your shipping agreement directly with the carrier; product dimensions and weights are entered completely; which carrier to work with in which region is decided in advance.
| Preparation | Why? |
|---|---|
| Shipping agreement | Integration details are obtained from the contracted account |
| Product dimensions and weight | Size-based rules work correctly |
| Region and customer rules | The suitable carrier is selected automatically |
| Sender details | Labels print correctly |
Missing product dimensions and weights effectively nullify a rule defined by size; for these fields, apply the completeness check in the article how to prepare a product card. After setup, transfer a selected order to the carrier and test the barcode and label; daily work comes down to the transfer-to-carrier button on the order list.
Recommended ReadingHow Do You Calculate Desi?Lesson 7: What does a customer exception cost?
In short: A customer-specific carrier setting is a service, but it has a cost. Calculate the cost and compare it with the profit that customer brings.
Example: A wholesale customer in Marmara receives 40 shipments a month and wants them sent with carrier B. Since A is ₺58 and B is ₺64 in Marmara, the difference is ₺6 per shipment, or 40 × 6 = ₺240 a month. If the customer's monthly profit is well above this, the exception is not a problem; for a small customer, however, the same exception is an unnecessary cost.
- Carrier A (Marmara)₺48040%
- Carrier B (the other five regions)₺72060%
Prepared with sample values. B's share is 60%.
| Exception | Monthly shipments | Price difference | Monthly cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marmara wholesale customer wants B | 40 | 6 ₺ | 240 ₺ |
| Customer in the East wants A | 15 | 7 ₺ | 105 ₺ |
The two exceptions total ₺345, which equals 10% of the ₺3,440 saving achieved with the region rule. If this ratio is small, you can comfortably keep the customer-specific rule; as the number of exceptions grows, the rule falls apart. For customer-level profitability, see the article how to calculate profitability by customer.
- ₺3,440monthly saving (compared with A)
- 4.3%drop in shipping cost
- ₺64.02cost per shipment with the rule
- ₺345monthly cost of the two customer exceptions
Lesson 8: How do you review the shipping rule monthly?
In short: Shipping prices, regional distribution and carrier quality change over time. Review the rule at least once a month with invoice and complaint data.
| When? | What to do? | Who? |
|---|---|---|
| Weekly | Delayed, damaged and returned shipments are listed | Operations |
| Monthly | Invoices are compared with the rule; region-based cost is calculated | Accounting |
| When prices are updated | The regional comparison is redone | Management |
| New customer or region | Special rules and exception costs are evaluated | Management |
| Once a quarter | Quality thresholds and the priority order are reviewed | Management |
Seeing shipping costs in the panel and comparing options helps you price correctly. For the profit calculation, see the profit margin calculator, and for the full order flow, the article how to manage orders in e-commerce. The article how to do order picking and packing is useful for the effect of warehouse packing on shipping desi.
Recommended ReadingHow Do You Check a Shipping Invoice?What are the most common mistakes in region-based shipping rules?
- Looking at the average price. Regional differences are hidden.
- Choosing by price alone. The cost of delays and damage is ignored.
- Not entering product dimensions and weight. Size rules do not work.
- Not setting rule priority. The customer rule conflicts with the region rule.
- Not calculating customer exceptions. Small costs add up.
- Setting up the rule once and forgetting it. The comparison becomes outdated when prices are updated.
- Not comparing the invoice with the rule. A wrong rate goes unnoticed.
How does NetKasam make shipping rules easier?
- Multiple carriers. You work with all integrated carriers at the same time.
- Region, province and district rules. The system selects the carrier suited to the delivery region and transfers the order automatically.
- Price and size settings. Rules by price and size are added for a carrier.
- Customer-specific carrier. The carrier the customer wants is assigned.
- Excel or manual entry. Shipments outside the panel are included in the same tracking flow.
- Tracking link. It is shared with the customer via WhatsApp, SMS or email; the information is also sent to the sales platform.
- Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.
Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.
- A region has 200 shipments; A is ₺60, B is ₺55. If we ship with B, what is the monthly saving?
- How much does this saving come to per year?
- If the total shipping cost for 1,000 shipments is ₺64,000, what is the cost per shipment?
- If the price difference on 30 shipments under a customer-specific rule is ₺5, what is the monthly cost?
- Why shouldn't you simply choose the cheapest carrier?
Answer key:
- 200 × (60 − 55) = 1.000 ₺.
- 1.000 × 12 = 12.000 ₺.
- 64.000 ÷ 1.000 = 64 ₺.
- 30 × 5 = 150 ₺.
- The cost of delays, damage and returns can wipe out the price advantage; the rule should evaluate price together with a quality threshold.
Frequently Asked Questions About Region-Based Shipping Rules
Can I work with more than one carrier at the same time?
Yes. You can work with all integrated carriers at the same time.
How do you choose a carrier by region?
When you define rules by region, province, district or customer, the system selects the carrier deemed suitable for the delivery region and transfers the order automatically.
What do you do if a customer wants to work with a specific carrier?
You can define a carrier specific to that customer; orders going to them are transferred to the carrier they want.
Does NetKasam make the shipping agreement?
No. You make the agreement directly with the carrier; NetKasam connects your existing agreement to the system.
Can rules be defined by price and size?
Yes. Rules can be defined for a carrier by price and size; for this, product dimensions and weight must be entered.
How much does choosing the cheapest carrier save?
It depends on the region-weighted price difference. In the example, 1,200 shipments a month saved ₺3,440 (4.3%); this figure is based on sample prices.
Can I track shipments made outside the panel?
Yes. You can bring your shipments into the system via Excel or manual entry and include them in the same tracking flow.
Does shipment tracking information go to the sales platform?
Yes. After shipped orders are transferred to the carrier, the information is sent to the sales platform.
Conclusion: Break down your latest shipping invoice by region this month
A shipping rule needs data first. This month, break down your latest invoice by region, write down the number of shipments and carrier prices for each region, and compare the cheapest choice with the single-carrier cost. Even if the difference is small, setting up the rule is a one-time job; once you add the quality threshold and customer exceptions, your shipping cost both drops and becomes predictable.
Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free
Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.