How Do You Lower Your Return Rate? A Guide to Return Costs, Category Breakdown, Return Reasons, Size Charts and Quality Control Measures, and Reselling
How do you lower the return rate? Return cost, category breakdown, return reasons, the impact of countermeasures and resale: an 8-lesson e-commerce guide with examples.
Contents 14 sections
- What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
- Lesson 1: Why should you monitor the return rate?
- Lesson 2: How do you calculate the return rate and return cost?
- Lesson 3: Which category is driving up the return rate?
- Lesson 4: How do you analyze return reasons?
- Lesson 5: How do measures change the number and cost of returns?
- Lesson 6: How do you make the post-return process cheaper?
- Lesson 7: How do you set up a return recording system?
- Lesson 8: How do you monitor the return rate?
- What are the most common mistakes in lowering the return rate?
- How does NetKasam make return tracking easier?
- Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
- Conclusion: Count last month's returns by reason
- Frequently Asked Questions About the Return Rate
You ship 2,000 orders a month and 200 come back. Your return rate is 10%. It's easy to dismiss this as "normal for the industry", but every return is not just a lost sale: it means outbound shipping, return shipping, packaging, inspection and products that become unsellable. Cutting the rate by four points is often a cheaper source of profit than finding new customers.
This article is not a narrative but an 8-lesson practical training. We will answer the question how do you lower the return rate using an e-commerce business that receives 2,000 orders a month: calculating the return rate and its cost, the category breakdown, analyzing return reasons, the impact and cost of four measures, the payoff of reselling returned products quickly, the recording system and monitoring indicators. At the end there is a mini quiz with an answer key. You can find the cost calculation for returns in the article how to calculate return cost; this article focuses on lowering the rate.
What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
In short: You will calculate the return rate and its cost, separate returns by category and reason, evaluate the impact of measures in numbers and make the post-return process cheaper.
- 01RateCalculate the return rate and its cost.
- 02CategoryFind the high-return category.
- 03ReasonCode and count return reasons.
- 04MeasureChoose a measure for each reason.
- 05ImpactCompare savings with the cost of the measure.
- 06MonitoringTrack the rate and reasons monthly.
The training's 8 lessons: (1) why the return rate is monitored, (2) the return rate and its cost, (3) the category breakdown, (4) return reasons, (5) measures and their impact, (6) making the post-return process cheaper, (7) the recording system and its use, (8) monitoring indicators.
Lesson 1: Why should you monitor the return rate?
In short: The return rate is an indicator of both money and customer experience. A high rate tells you there is a problem somewhere in product information, quality or delivery; but the reasons show where the problem is.
Businesses usually see returns as a cost item, glance at the overall rate and move on. Yet two businesses with the same 10% can have completely different problems: one has size mismatches, the other damaged packages. The right measure comes after you name the problem. That's why recording the reason as soon as you receive a return notice is the foundation of the whole analysis.
Example business: 2,000 orders a month, average basket ₺400, product cost 60%, payment commission 2%, shipping per order ₺55, packaging ₺10. The contribution of an order that isn't returned is 400 − 240 − 8 − 55 − 10 = ₺87. Orders are split across four categories: apparel, footwear, accessories and home products.
Lesson 2: How do you calculate the return rate and return cost?
In short: The return rate is the number of returned orders divided by the total number of orders. The cost per return is the sum of shipping, packaging, handling and the share of products that can't be sold.
- Return rate = Returned orders ÷ Total orders
- Cost per return = Outbound shipping + Return shipping + Packaging + Handling + Unsellable product share
- Monthly return cost = Number of returns × Cost per return
Prepared with sample values.
| Item | Amount | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Outbound shipping | 55 ₺ | Shipping for the package sent to the customer is wasted |
| Return shipping | 55 ₺ | Return fee for the return package |
| Packing | 10 ₺ | The original packing labor is wasted |
| Handling and inspection | 15 ₺ | Receiving, inspecting and reshelving the returned product |
| Unsellable product share | 48 ₺ | 20% of returns can't be resold (0.20 × ₺240 cost) |
| Direct cost per return | 183 ₺ | 55 + 55 + 10 + 15 + 48 |
Monthly cost: 200 returns × ₺183 = ₺36,600. Add the lost contribution: had it not been returned, each order would have left ₺87 of contribution; 200 × 87 = ₺17,400. The total difference is ₺54,000 a month, or ₺270 per return. The return rate is 10%, but the share of returns in revenue turns into a much larger profit loss. For margin context, see the article how to calculate profit margin.
Lesson 3: Which category is driving up the return rate?
In short: The overall rate hides return rates that vary widely by category. A category-level calculation shows where to focus your measures.
| Category | Order | Return | Return rate | Monthly direct cost (₺183) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clothing | 600 | 108 | %18,0 | 19.764 ₺ |
| Shoes | 300 | 48 | %16,0 | 8.784 ₺ |
| Accessories | 500 | 25 | %5,0 | 4.575 ₺ |
| Home products | 600 | 19 | %3,2 | 3.477 ₺ |
| Total | 2.000 | 200 | %10,0 | 36.600 ₺ |
- Apparel18.0%
- Footwear16.0%
- Accessories5.0%
- Home products3.2%
Prepared with example values. The overall return rate is 10%.
Check: 108 + 48 + 25 + 19 = 200 returns; 19,764 + 8,784 + 4,575 + 3,477 = ₺36,600. Apparel and footwear make up 45% of orders but generate 78% of return costs (28,548 ÷ 36,600). Concentrating measures on these two categories is far more efficient than spreading them across all products. The same logic applies at the product level: a few products with high return rates often explain half of the return problem. We covered product-level profitability in the article how to analyze product profitability.
Lesson 4: How do you analyze return reasons?
In short: Enter a single reason code for every return notice and count the reasons at month-end. The breakdown of reasons shows which measure should come first.
- Size or fit problem₺7035%
- Product didn't meet expectations₺5025%
- Damaged or defective product₺3015%
- Wrong product sent₺2010%
- Late delivery₺2010%
- Other₺105%
Prepared with sample values.
| Reason | Return | Share | Monthly direct cost | Who controls it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Size or fit problem | 70 | %35 | 12.810 ₺ | Product page, size chart |
| Product didn't meet expectations | 50 | %25 | 9.150 ₺ | Accuracy of images and description |
| Damaged or defective product | 30 | %15 | 5.490 ₺ | Supplier quality, packaging |
| Wrong product sent | 20 | %10 | 3.660 ₺ | Warehouse and order preparation |
| Late delivery | 20 | %10 | 3.660 ₺ | Carrier, regional rule |
| Other | 10 | %5 | 1.830 ₺ | – |
Check: 70 + 50 + 30 + 20 + 20 + 10 = 200; total costs 12,810 + 9,150 + 5,490 + 3,660 + 3,660 + 1,830 = ₺36,600. The last column of the table matters: 60% of returns relate to information on the product page and 25% to warehouse and quality processes. In other words, most of the return problem stems not from customer behavior but from information within the business's own control. If the "Other" code exceeds 10%, expand the reason list, because a problem without a name can't be solved.
Recommended readingHow Do You Calculate Return Cost?Lesson 5: How do measures change the number and cost of returns?
In short: You calculate the impact of each reason-specific measure as the reduction in returns, and its savings by multiplying that by the cost per return and subtracting the cost of the measure. If the net result is positive, the measure is worthwhile.
| Reason | Prevention | Assumed reduction | Returns prevented | Monthly saving (₺183) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Size or fit | Size chart, measurement info, model's height and size | %30 | 21 | 3.843 ₺ |
| Unmet expectations | Real photos, accurate color, detailed description | %20 | 10 | 1.830 ₺ |
| Damage and wrong product | Pre-dispatch quality control, sturdy packaging | 40% (of 50 returns) | 20 | 3.660 ₺ |
| Late delivery | Region-based carrier selection, delivery time notice | %25 | 5 | 915 ₺ |
The reduction rates are example assumptions; determine them through your own tests. Total returns prevented: 21 + 10 + 20 + 5 = 56. New number of returns: 200 − 56 = 144, a rate of 7.2%. Monthly cost of the measures: extra labor for pre-dispatch quality control ₺1,500 (2,000 orders × ₺0.75) and content preparation (size chart, photos, description) spread over months at ₺800, for a total of ₺2,300.
- Current monthly return cost₺36,600
- Size and fit measure (21 returns)−₺3,843
- Product information measure (10 returns)−₺1,830
- Quality control and packaging (20 returns)−₺3,660
- Delivery rule (5 returns)−₺915
- Monthly cost of the measures₺2,300
- Monthly return cost with the measures₺28,652
Prepared with example values. Total: 36,600 − 3,843 − 1,830 − 3,660 − 915 + 2,300 = ₺28,652.
Net saving 36,600 − 28,652 = ₺7,948; that is, the ₺2,300 cost of the measures has been deducted from the gross saving of ₺10,248. The contribution of the 56 orders that aren't returned is also preserved: 56 × 87 = ₺4,872 of additional gain. Altogether, that's an improvement of about ₺12,800 a month. The highest-return measure is the size chart, because it targets the biggest reason and requires only one-time preparation. Quality control, meanwhile, reduces both damaged and wrong-product returns at the same time with a low investment. You can find the packing routine for damage and wrong products in the article how to pick and pack orders, and the delivery rule in how to create region-based shipping rules.
Lesson 6: How do you make the post-return process cheaper?
In short: Inspecting returned products quickly and putting them back on sale lowers the unsellable product share. This share is one of the biggest changeable items in the cost per return.
In the example, 20% of returns can't be resold; this is usually because the product was inspected late, its packaging was damaged or its season passed. Inspecting the returned product and shelving it the day it is received can lower this rate.
| Unsellable rate | Loss share per return | Total cost per return | Monthly cost for 200 returns |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20% (current) | 48 ₺ | 183 ₺ | 36.600 ₺ |
| %15 | 36 ₺ | 171 ₺ | 34.200 ₺ |
| %10 | 24 ₺ | 159 ₺ | 31.800 ₺ |
Lowering the unsellable rate from 20% to 10% saves ₺4,800 a month without changing the number of returns (200 × ₺24). This improvement is independent of the measures in Lesson 5 and can be applied alongside them. Standardize the inspection step: the returned product is opened, its condition recorded, and if sellable it goes into inventory the same day; if not, it is set aside with a separate record. For the return invoice and inventory record, see the articles how to issue a return invoice and how to find and close inventory discrepancies.
Lesson 7: How do you set up a return recording system?
In short: Each return is kept on a single row: order, product, category, reason code, shipping details, resellability and resolution. The analysis comes from these rows.
| Area | Example | Why it's needed |
|---|---|---|
| Order and product | Order no., product, variant | Product-level rate |
| Category | Apparel, footwear | Category-level rate |
| Reason code | Size, expectations, damage, wrong product, late delivery | Choosing measures |
| Resellability | Yes / no | Unsellable product share |
| Solution | Refund, exchange | Invoice and inventory record |
You get more reliable results when you collect reason codes from the return form rather than by asking the customer; but also keep the free text the customer writes, because frequently recurring words inside the "Other" code may point to a new reason category. For customer communication templates, see the article how to send order updates to customers.
In NetKasam you can track marketplace and e-commerce orders on one screen, update order statuses, cancel or partially cancel when needed, issue invoices for returns, see return entries in the inventory movements report and export saved reports to Excel. For details, see the order management, inventory management and reports pages. For size-level return tracking on products with variants, the article how to manage products with variants on marketplaces helps.
Lesson 8: How do you monitor the return rate?
In short: Track six indicators monthly: return rate, category-level rate, reason breakdown, cost per return, unsellable product rate and monthly return cost. If the share of one reason grows, update the list of measures.
| Indicator | Sample value | How it is calculated |
|---|---|---|
| Return rate | %10 | Returns ÷ Orders (200 ÷ 2,000) |
| Highest category rate | Apparel: 18% | Category returns ÷ Category orders |
| Largest reason share | Size: 35% | Returns for reason ÷ Total returns |
| Cost per return | 183 ₺ | Outbound + return + packaging + handling + loss share |
| Unsellable product rate | %20 | Unsellable returns ÷ Total returns |
| Monthly return cost | 36.600 ₺ | Number of returns × Cost per return |
- ₺270total difference per return (₺183 cost + ₺87 lost contribution)
- 78%share of apparel and footwear in return costs
- 7.2%return rate after the measures (down from 10%)
- ₺7,948monthly net saving after deducting the cost of the measures
If the return rate isn't falling, look at the reason breakdown first; perhaps the measure was applied to the wrong reason. If a reason's share is growing, a new problem has emerged: a new supplier, a new product line, a new carrier. To do the monthly monitoring together with other operational indicators, see the article how to prepare a weekly management report. For defect returns caused by suppliers, the article how to measure supplier performance is a useful complement.
Recommended readingHow Do You Measure Supplier Performance?What are the most common mistakes in lowering the return rate?
- Looking only at the overall rate. Without a category and reason breakdown, there's no solution.
- Not collecting reason codes. Measures end up based on guesswork.
- Spreading a measure across all products. Focusing on a few high-return categories is more efficient.
- Not calculating the cost of a measure. The net saving remains unknown.
- Inspecting returned products late. The unsellable product rate rises.
- Not updating the product page. Expectation-related returns continue.
- Blaming returns solely on the customer. Most reasons come from the business's own information and processes.
How does NetKasam make return tracking easier?
- Single-screen order management. You see orders and return statuses together and cancel or partially cancel (order management).
- Return invoice. You correct the invoice for a returned order and keep the accounting records consistent (e-Invoice).
- Inventory movements report. You see return entries and products put back on sale on record (inventory management).
- Products with variants. You track inventory and returns by size and color.
- Filters and bulk actions. You filter orders with returns and update them in bulk.
- Saved reports. You save the returns report, export it to Excel and calculate the reason and category breakdown in your own table (reports).
- Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.
Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.
- If outbound shipping is ₺50, return shipping ₺50, packaging ₺10, handling ₺10 and the unsellable product share ₺30, what is the cost per return?
- 80 of 1,000 orders were returned. What is the return rate?
- What is the monthly direct return cost?
- 30 of 80 returns are size-related, and a measure reduces them by 30%. What is the monthly saving?
- Category A: 500 orders, 60 returns; Category B: 500 orders, 20 returns. Which category is above the overall rate?
Answer key:
- 50 + 50 + 10 + 10 + 30 = 150 ₺.
- 80 ÷ 1.000 = %8.
- 80 × 150 = 12.000 ₺.
- Returns prevented 30 × 0.30 = 9; saving 9 × 150 = ₺1,350.
- Category A 12%, Category B 4%, overall rate 8%; A is above the overall rate.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Return Rate
How do you lower the return rate?
You break returns down by category and reason, take reason-specific measures (size chart, accurate product information, quality control, delivery rules) and track the results monthly.
How is the return rate calculated?
You divide the number of returned orders by the total number of orders. Calculating it separately by product and category is more instructive.
What does a return cost?
It is the sum of outbound and return shipping, packaging, handling and the share of products that can't be resold. Add to that the order contribution you would have earned had it not been returned.
How do you collect return reasons?
By using a mandatory list of reasons and a short free-text field on the return form. If the "Other" share is high, the list is expanded.
Which measure reduces returns the most?
In the example, size and fit returns are the biggest reason, and a size chart and accurate product information deliver the highest savings. Decide based on your own reason breakdown.
Why should a returned product be inspected quickly?
A product inspected late can become unsellable. If the unsellable product rate falls from 20% to 10%, the example saves ₺4,800 a month.
How do you evaluate the cost of return measures?
Multiply the number of returns prevented by the cost per return to find the gross savings, then subtract the measure's monthly cost. If the net result is positive, the measure is worthwhile.
How does NetKasam help with return tracking?
It manages orders on one screen and offers return invoices, an inventory movements report, variant-based inventory and saved reports; bookkeeping is free.
Conclusion: Count last month's returns by reason
The most useful thing you can do today is count last month's returns by five or six reasons and write them in a table. The biggest reason determines your first measure; your cost per return shows how much you can invest in that measure. The next step is to make the reason choice mandatory on the return form and update product pages according to these reasons.
Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free
Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.