How Do You Measure the Post-Campaign Sales Dip? A Guide to the Baseline, Pulled-Forward Demand, Net Incremental Orders, Real Profit Impact, Break-Even Order Count and the Campaign Scorecard
How do you measure the post-campaign sales dip? Baseline, pulled-forward demand, the real profit impact and the breakeven number of orders: an 8-lesson guide with examples.
Contents 14 sections
- What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
- Lesson 1: Why is a simple measurement misleading?
- Lesson 2: How do you set a baseline?
- Lesson 3: How do you measure the post-campaign dip?
- Lesson 4: What are net extra orders and pulled-forward demand?
- Lesson 5: How do you calculate a campaign's real profit impact?
- Lesson 6: What are the breakeven number of orders and the dip threshold?
- Lesson 7: How do you reduce the post-campaign dip?
- Lesson 8: How do you keep a campaign scorecard?
- What are the most common mistakes when measuring the post-campaign dip?
- How does NetKasam make post-campaign tracking easier?
- Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
- Conclusion: Write down the threshold before your next campaign
- Frequently Asked Questions About the Post-Campaign Sales Dip
During the campaign week, orders nearly double, green arrows appear on the dashboard and the campaign is declared a success. Two weeks later, orders fall below normal, but the dip isn't linked to the campaign; people say "the season slowed down". Yet a campaign's real result can only be understood by looking not just at the campaign week but at the total of the weeks before and after it.
This article is not a narrative but an 8-lesson practical training. We will answer the question how do you measure the post-campaign sales dip using a one-week campaign at an example business that receives 1,000 orders a week: why ordinary measurement misleads, how to set a baseline, calculating the post-campaign dip, net extra orders, the profit calculation, the breakeven number of orders, ways to reduce the dip and the campaign scorecard. At the end there is a mini quiz with an answer key. All figures are example values chosen to illustrate the method; follow the same steps with your own data.
What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
In short: You will set a baseline for the campaign, measure the post-campaign dip, calculate the campaign's real three-week contribution and plan the next campaign around the breakeven point.
- 01Set a baselineFind weekly orders without a campaign.
- 02MeasureCalculate the campaign week's extra orders.
- 03Find the dipWrite down the shortfall in the following weeks.
- 04Compare contributionCompare the three weeks' contribution with the no-campaign scenario.
- 05Find the thresholdCalculate the breakeven number of orders.
- 06Score itRecord every campaign on the same scorecard.
The training's 8 lessons: (1) why simple measurement misleads, (2) how to set a baseline, (3) how to measure the post-campaign dip, (4) net extra orders, (5) the profit calculation, (6) the breakeven number of orders and the dip threshold, (7) how to reduce the dip, (8) the campaign scorecard.
Lesson 1: Why is a simple measurement misleading?
In short: Comparing only the campaign week with a normal week credits all the extra orders to the campaign. But some of these orders would have come in the following weeks anyway.
- Campaign week extra orders = Campaign week orders − Baseline
- Post-campaign dip = Baseline − Orders in the weeks after the campaign (sum of the negative differences)
- Net extra orders = Campaign week extra orders − Post-campaign dip
The example business ran a one-week campaign at 10% off. It received 1,900 orders in the campaign week; normal weekly orders are 1,000. A simple measurement says 1,900 − 1,000 = 900 extra orders, and the campaign appears to have delivered 90% growth. But this calculation misses two things: what happened after the campaign, and the fact that each order contributes less because of the discount. Orders falling below normal two weeks later may show that the campaign didn't create demand but merely pulled it forward. To do the profit calculation for a discount before the campaign, see also the article how to offer discounts without losing money.
Lesson 2: How do you set a baseline?
In short: The baseline is an estimate of the weekly orders you would expect had there been no campaign. The simplest approach is the average of the four weeks before the campaign.
In the example, orders in the four weeks before the campaign were 980, 1,020, 990 and 1,010. The total is 4,000, the average 4,000 ÷ 4 = 1,000 orders. This value is the baseline; had there been no campaign, about 1,000 orders would have been expected in the following weeks too. When setting the baseline, pay attention to three points:
- Choosing the period. If the previous weeks included another campaign, a holiday or a shipping disruption, those weeks are left out of the average; the four weeks should reflect the period's true normal.
- Trend. If sales are already rising or falling, a flat average misleads; also take into account the same period last year or the slope of the last four weeks. To build a sales forecast, see the article how to forecast sales.
- Seasonality. If the campaign runs at the start or end of a season, the baseline should include the season's own movement; otherwise the season's effect gets credited to the campaign. For seasonal products, the calendar logic in the article how to plan seasonal product inventory helps.
The baseline isn't an exact truth but a reasonable estimate. Calculating the same campaign with more than one baseline (a four-week average and the same period last year) shows how much the result depends on the estimate. Setting separate lines by product group also gives a clearer result; for this split, you can use the grouping method in the article how to analyze product profitability.
Lesson 3: How do you measure the post-campaign dip?
In short: Compare each week's orders after the campaign with the baseline; the sum of the shortfalls below normal is the dip. The dip is tracked until orders return to normal.
| Week | Order | Baseline | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 weeks before the campaign (average) | 1.000 | 1.000 | 0 |
| Campaign week | 1.900 | 1.000 | +900 |
| 1 week after the campaign | 760 | 1.000 | −240 |
| 2 weeks after the campaign | 880 | 1.000 | −120 |
| 3 weeks after the campaign | 1.000 | 1.000 | 0 |
- Before the campaign (average)1,000 orders
- Campaign week1,900 orders
- 1 week after760 orders
- 2 weeks after880 orders
- 3 weeks after1,000 orders
Prepared with example values. The baseline is a level of 1,000 orders a week.
The shortfall in the first week is 240 and in the second week 120; in the third week orders return to normal, so tracking ends there. The total dip is a shortfall of 240 + 120 = 360 orders. The number of weeks the dip lasts depends on the product: for regularly used products such as consumables, the dip lasts longer because customers stock up; for gift or seasonal products, it is short. You can only tell the dip is over when orders return to the baseline two weeks in a row.
Lesson 4: What are net extra orders and pulled-forward demand?
In short: Net extra orders are found by subtracting the post-campaign dip from the campaign week's extra orders. The dip's share of the extra orders shows how much demand was simply pulled forward.
In the example, the campaign week brought 900 extra orders and 360 orders were missing in the following weeks. Net extra orders are 900 − 360 = 540. The share of pulled-forward demand is 360 ÷ 900 = 40%: forty percent of the campaign week's extra orders were simply customers shifting orders they would have placed anyway into the discount week.
- Truly new orders₺54060%
- Pulled-forward orders₺36040%
Prepared with example values. Net extra: 900 − 360 = 540; pulled forward: 360.
This rate determines the campaign's efficiency. A 40% pull-forward rate means the campaign delivered nearly half of its growth through nothing more than a change in timing. If pull-forward is high, the campaign changed existing customers' purchase timing more than it won new customers. To measure the cost of new customers separately, see the article how to calculate customer acquisition cost.
Lesson 5: How do you calculate a campaign's real profit impact?
In short: A campaign's real impact is the difference between the total contribution of the three weeks with the campaign and the total contribution of the three weeks without it.
In the example business, the average basket is ₺500 and the normal order contribution is ₺150 (after deducting product, commission, shipping and packaging). A 10% discount takes ₺50 off the basket; the contribution of a campaign order becomes 150 − 50 = ₺100.
Simple measurement: The campaign week has 1,900 × 100 = ₺190,000 of contribution; a normal week has 1,000 × 150 = ₺150,000. The difference is +₺40,000, and the campaign looks profitable.
Real measurement (three weeks): In the no-campaign scenario, the three weeks would have contributed 3 × 1,000 × 150 = ₺450,000. In the campaign scenario, week by week:
| Week | Order | Contribution per order | Contribution | Baseline contribution | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Campaign week | 1.900 | 100 ₺ | 190.000 ₺ | 150.000 ₺ | +40.000 ₺ |
| 1 week after | 760 | 150 ₺ | 114.000 ₺ | 150.000 ₺ | −36.000 ₺ |
| 2 weeks after | 880 | 150 ₺ | 132.000 ₺ | 150.000 ₺ | −18.000 ₺ |
| Total | 3.540 | 436.000 ₺ | 450.000 ₺ | −14.000 ₺ |
- Contribution of three weeks without the campaign₺450,000
- Difference in the campaign week₺40,000
- Difference 1 week after the campaign−₺36,000
- Difference 2 weeks after the campaign−₺18,000
- Contribution of the three campaign weeks₺436,000
Prepared with example values. Total: 450,000 + 40,000 − 36,000 − 18,000 = ₺436,000. The campaign's net impact: −₺14,000.
While the simple measurement showed +₺40,000 profit, the campaign actually posted a loss of 436,000 − 450,000 = −₺14,000. Advertising, coupons and extra operating expenses weren't included in this calculation; adding them makes the loss bigger. You can find how contribution is calculated in the article how to calculate profit margin, and with every item per order in the article how to calculate cost per order.
Lesson 6: What are the breakeven number of orders and the dip threshold?
In short: You can calculate in advance how many orders you need to reach in the campaign week and above what level the dip will turn the campaign into a loss.
Breakeven number of orders. Assuming the same dip (1,640 orders in total over two weeks), let the three weeks' contribution equal the no-campaign scenario. The contribution of the following two weeks is 1,640 × 150 = ₺246,000. The required campaign week contribution is 450,000 − 246,000 = ₺204,000. Since the contribution of a campaign order is ₺100, the required orders are 204,000 ÷ 100 = 2,040. So the campaign week needed at least 2,040 orders, 1,040 above the baseline; with 1,900 orders, this threshold was missed by 140 orders.
Dip threshold. Another view: had there been no dip at all, the campaign week would have gained +₺40,000. Each lost order takes away ₺150 of contribution; profit drops to zero at a loss of 40,000 ÷ 150 = 266.7 orders. That is 29.6% of the campaign week's extra orders (900). If the dip is larger than this share, the campaign is at a loss; in the example, the dip of 360 exceeded this threshold.
| Dip scenario | Orders lost over the next two weeks | Three-week contribution difference | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| No dip | 0 | +40.000 ₺ | Profitable |
| Dip in the example | 360 | −14.000 ₺ | Loss-making |
| Large dip | 600 | −50.000 ₺ | Loss-making |
The table shows that every 100 lost orders take away ₺15,000: the no-dip scenario is +₺40,000, −₺14,000 at 360 orders and −₺50,000 at 600 orders. Write down these two thresholds (the required number of orders and the acceptable dip) before the campaign. Also choose the discount rate per product according to the threshold: a lower discount increases the contribution of a campaign order and lowers the number of orders required. You can see the same logic for deciding whether to join marketplace campaigns in the article how to decide whether to join a marketplace campaign.
Recommended readingHow Do You Offer Discounts Without Losing Money?Lesson 7: How do you reduce the post-campaign dip?
In short: The way to reduce the dip is to direct the discount not at everyone but at new customers and old stock, keep the campaign short and leave demand for after the campaign.
- Target new customers. Prevent existing customers from buying at a discount what they would have bought anyway; a first-order campaign reduces pull-forward. Measure the lasting value of new customers with the article how to calculate customer lifetime value.
- Focus on old stock. A discount on products that have been sitting on the shelf for a long time doesn't pull forward an order the customer would have placed anyway, because no orders are expected for that product, so the campaign genuinely creates extra demand. Find out which stock is aging with the article how to do an inventory aging analysis.
- Keep it short. In a long campaign, customers plan their shopping around the campaign dates; a short, clear end date limits this planning. Still, measure the effect in your own data.
- Be careful with consumables. A customer who buys a regularly used product at a discount won't order in the following months; limit the campaign rule by quantity.
- Set up a post-campaign trigger. A message or bundle recommending other products during the dip period partly fills the gap. To measure repeat order behavior, see the article how to calculate and increase the repeat purchase rate.
- Plan your stock preparation. If stock runs out during the campaign, demand is lost; to prepare for busy periods, see the article how to prepare for a peak campaign period.
Lesson 8: How do you keep a campaign scorecard?
In short: Record every campaign with the same five indicators; that way you can compare campaigns with each other and set the next one's threshold based on previous experience.
| Indicator | How it is calculated | Sample value |
|---|---|---|
| Campaign week extra orders | Campaign week − Baseline | 900 |
| Post-campaign dip | Sum of the shortfalls below normal | 360 |
| Share of pulled-forward demand | Dip ÷ Campaign week extra orders | %40 |
| Net extra orders | Extra orders − Dip | 540 |
| Three-week contribution difference | Contribution with campaign − Contribution without campaign | −14.000 ₺ |
- +900extra orders in the campaign week
- 40%share of pulled-forward demand
- −₺14,000real contribution difference over three weeks
- 29.6%dip threshold that turns the campaign into a loss
Fill in the scorecard after every campaign, once the dip period is also over. After a few campaigns you will see which discount rate, which product group and which duration reduces the dip. To make the scorecard part of your weekly summary, see the article how to prepare a weekly management report, and to track it alongside targets, how to set and track sales targets.
Recommended readingHow Do You Calculate the Cost of Manual Order Processing? Training on Step Times, Error Cost, Cost per Order, Automation Breakeven and Staffing NeedsWhat are the most common mistakes when measuring the post-campaign dip?
- Looking only at the campaign week. If the dip period isn't included, the campaign looks more profitable than it really is.
- Not choosing a baseline. If the normal to compare against is unknown, the extra orders estimate is wasted.
- Counting campaign orders at full contribution. The discount lowers each order's contribution; do the calculation with post-discount contribution.
- Blaming the dip on the season. A post-campaign dip isn't always seasonal movement; make sure the baseline includes the season.
- Not calculating the threshold in advance. If the required number of orders isn't known up front, the campaign's success is left to interpretation afterward.
- Stopping tracking too early. You know the dip is over when orders return to the baseline for two weeks.
How does NetKasam make post-campaign tracking easier?
- You set up the campaign. A campaign is defined for a product, category or store and given a date range (in-store POS screen).
- Orders in one panel. Marketplace and e-commerce orders are gathered on one screen; you see weekly order counts by channel (order management).
- Saved reports. You save the sales report for before, during and after the campaign and export it to Excel (reports).
- Inventory drops instantly. Each sale creates an inventory movement; you get a notification at critical stock levels (inventory management).
- Invoice tracking. You track issued invoices and returns (invoice tracking).
- Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.
Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.
- If orders in the four weeks before the campaign were 980, 1,020, 990 and 1,010, what is the baseline?
- If there were 1,900 orders in the campaign week and the baseline is 1,000, what are the campaign week's extra orders?
- If 760 and 880 orders came in over the two weeks after the campaign, with a baseline of 1,000, what is the total dip?
- If extra orders are 900 and the dip is 360, what percentage is the share of pulled-forward demand?
- If the contribution of a campaign order is ₺100 and that of a normal order ₺150, what is the difference between the contribution of 1,900 campaign orders and that of 1,000 normal orders?
Answer key:
- (980 + 1.020 + 990 + 1.010) ÷ 4 = 4.000 ÷ 4 = 1.000.
- 1.900 − 1.000 = 900.
- (1.000 − 760) + (1.000 − 880) = 240 + 120 = 360.
- 360 ÷ 900 = %40.
- 1,900 × 100 = 190,000; 1,000 × 150 = 150,000; difference +₺40,000.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Post-Campaign Sales Dip
What is the post-campaign sales dip?
It is when orders fall below normal in the weeks after a discount campaign because the campaign pulled customers' future purchases forward.
What is a baseline?
It is an estimate of the weekly orders you would expect had there been no campaign. The simplest approach is the average of the four weeks before the campaign.
How do you measure a campaign's real impact?
The total contribution of the campaign week and the following dip weeks is compared with the contribution of the same weeks without a campaign. The difference is the campaign's net impact.
How do you calculate pulled-forward demand?
The total of the orders that fell below normal after the campaign is divided by the extra orders in the campaign week. In the example, 360 ÷ 900 = 40%.
When does a campaign turn into a loss?
When the number of lost orders exceeds the campaign week's profit increase divided by the normal contribution per order. In the example this threshold was 266.7 orders, while the actual dip was 360.
How long does the dip last?
It depends on the product. It lasts longer for consumables and shorter for gift or seasonal products. Orders returning to the baseline two weeks in a row signal that the dip is over.
What can be done to reduce the dip?
Target new customers, focus on old stock, keep the campaign short, set quantity limits on consumables and plan an offer for after the campaign.
Which indicators should a campaign scorecard include?
Extra orders, the post-campaign dip, the share of pulled-forward demand, net extra orders and the three-week contribution difference. Every campaign should be recorded with the same indicators.
Conclusion: Write down the threshold before your next campaign
The most useful thing you can do today is write the average of the four weeks before your last campaign side by side with the orders of the two weeks after it. The resulting dip tells you how much of the campaign was really just pull-forward. The next step is to write down, before your next campaign, the required number of orders and the dip you are willing to accept.
Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free
Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.