How Do You Offer Discounts Without Losing Money? A Guide to Post-Discount Profit, Break-Even Sales Increase and Campaign Profitability
How do you discount without making a loss? Post-discount profit, the break-even sales increase formula, commission effect and campaign expenses: an 8-lesson training with examples.
Contents 14 sections
- What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
- Lesson 1: Why does a discount shrink profit by more than its rate?
- Lesson 2: How are unit contribution and contribution margin calculated?
- Lesson 3: How does the break-even sales increase formula work?
- Lesson 4: How does commission affect a discount on a marketplace?
- Lesson 5: How do campaign expenses change the break-even point?
- Lesson 6: How is the stock and cash impact calculated?
- Lesson 7: Which products should be discounted?
- Lesson 8: How do you do post-campaign measurement and the checklist?
- What are the most common mistakes in discounting without making a loss?
- How do you track campaign profitability with NetKasam?
- Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
- Conclusion: write down the threshold before the campaign
- Frequently Asked Questions About Discounting Without Making a Loss
You put up the "20% off everything!" banner, sales doubled, and the till is overflowing. At the end of the month, when you look at the books, you see that you made less profit than last month. This is not surprising: a discount grows the sales figure but often shrinks profit. That is because a discount cuts not only the price but also the money left from each sale, while your cost stays the same as without the discount.
This article is not a narrative but an 8-lesson hands-on training. We will answer the question how do you discount without making a loss with a single formula: from the relationship between discount rate and profit margin, we will find how many units you need to sell in the campaign. Then we will work through the effect of marketplace commission, campaign expenses, the stock and cash impact, and which products to discount, with numbers. There is a mini quiz and a campaign checklist at the end.
What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
In short: You will find a product's unit contribution and contribution margin, calculate the required sales increase for each discount rate, add the effect of marketplace commission, include campaign expenses in the threshold and evaluate the campaign by its actual results.
- 01ContributionCalculate the product's unit contribution and contribution margin.
- 02ThresholdFind the break-even sales increase for the discount rate.
- 03ExpensesAdd the effect of commission, advertising, shipping and returns.
- 04StockVerify there is stock to cover the target quantity.
- 05SelectionIdentify the products suitable for discounting.
- 06MeasurementCalculate the real contribution at the end of the campaign.
The 8 lessons of the training: (1) why a discount shrinks profit, (2) unit contribution and contribution margin, (3) the break-even sales increase formula, (4) the effect of commission on marketplaces, (5) campaign expenses, (6) stock and cash impact, (7) which products to discount, (8) post-campaign measurement and checklist.
Lesson 1: Why does a discount shrink profit by more than its rate?
In short: A discount lowers the price, but product, shipping and packaging costs stay the same. That is why the entire discount comes straight out of profit: a 10% discount cuts the price by 10%, but often cuts unit profit by more than 30%.
Our sample product sells for ₺1,000. The total of variable costs such as product purchase cost, commission, shipping and packaging is ₺700 (the figures are chosen only to illustrate the method; in this lesson we assume costs stay fixed as an amount). Unit profit is ₺300. Now let's apply a 10% discount:
| Without discount | With 10% discount | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sale price | 1.000 ₺ | 900 ₺ | −%10 |
| Variable cost | 700 ₺ | 700 ₺ | Same |
| Unit contribution | 300 ₺ | 200 ₺ | −%33,3 |
| Contribution margin | %30 | %22,2 | −7.8 points |
The price falls by 10% and unit profit by 33.3%. If you sell the same quantity, profit falls by a third; to avoid a loss, you need to sell more. To understand how low your margin is, first see the guide how to calculate profit margin and the profit margin calculator.
Lesson 2: How are unit contribution and contribution margin calculated?
In short: Unit contribution = sale price − variable costs. A variable cost is any expense that grows with sales volume: product cost, marketplace commission, shipping, packaging, payment commission. Fixed expenses such as rent and salaries are not included; the discount decision is made on the basis of unit contribution.
- Unit contribution = Sale price − Variable costs
- Contribution margin (m) = Unit contribution ÷ Selling price
- Discounted unit contribution = Unit contribution − Discount amount
- Break-even sales increase = d ÷ (m − d)
- Break-even quantity = Normal quantity × m ÷ (m − d)
- Campaign contribution = Campaign quantity × Discounted unit contribution − Campaign expenses
d: discount rate, m: contribution margin. The formula assumes variable costs stay fixed as an amount.
| Variable cost item | Example (₺1,000 product) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Product purchase cost | 450 ₺ | Depends on the inventory costing method; see inventory cost |
| Marketplace commission | 150 ₺ (%15) | Varies by category; changes with the price |
| Shipping and packaging | 100 ₺ | Based on desi; see how to calculate desi |
| Unit contribution | 300 ₺ | 30% contribution margin |
To list the real items on a marketplace one by one, use the article how to calculate net profit on a marketplace.
Lesson 3: How does the break-even sales increase formula work?
In short: To avoid a loss, unit sales need to increase by d ÷ (m − d). The lower your margin, the larger the increase required for the same discount.
Example: contribution margin 30%, discount 10%. Required increase = 0.10 ÷ (0.30 − 0.10) = 0.50, i.e. 50%. If you normally sell 200 units a month, you must sell at least 300 units in the campaign. Check: 200 × ₺300 = ₺60,000 normal contribution; 300 × ₺200 = ₺60,000 campaign contribution. The same contribution requires 50% more sales.
- Normal monthly contribution (200 units × ₺300)₺60,000
- Discount loss (200 units × ₺100)−₺20,000
- Contribution at the same quantity₺40,000
- 100 additional units × ₺200₺20,000
- Break-even contribution (300 units)₺60,000
Prepared with sample values.
| Discount rate | Calculation (m = 30%) | Required sales increase | Instead of 200 units |
|---|---|---|---|
| %5 | 0,05 ÷ 0,25 | %20 | 240 units |
| %10 | 0,10 ÷ 0,20 | %50 | 300 units |
| %15 | 0,15 ÷ 0,15 | %100 | 400 units |
| %20 | 0,20 ÷ 0,10 | %200 | 600 units |
| %25 | 0,25 ÷ 0,05 | %500 | 1,200 units |
| %30 | 0,30 ÷ 0 | Not possible | Zero profit on every sale |
Margin is the main variable that determines the table. The required increase for the same 10% discount at different contribution margins:
- Margin 15%200%
- Margin 20%100%
- Margin 30%50%
- Margin 40%33.3%
- Margin 50%25%
Prepared with sample values. Formula: 0.10 ÷ (m − 0.10).
To quickly try your own discount rate, you can also use the discount calculator.
Recommended readingHow Do You Calculate the Break-Even Point?Lesson 4: How does commission affect a discount on a marketplace?
In short: If marketplace commission is taken as a percentage of the sale price, the commission amount falls along with the discount; this softens the discount's effect on profit. The required sales increase becomes somewhat smaller than in the calculation without commission.
Let's sell the same product on a marketplace. Price ₺1,000, commission 15% (₺150), other variable costs ₺550; unit contribution is again ₺300. At a 10% discount, the price is ₺900, commission ₺135, contribution = 900 − 135 − 550 = ₺215 (it was ₺200 in the calculation without commission). Required increase = 300 ÷ 215 − 1 = 39.5% (it was 50% in the calculation without commission).
| Without discount | With 10% discount | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | 1.000 ₺ | 900 ₺ |
| Commission (15%) | 150 ₺ | 135 ₺ |
| Other variable costs | 550 ₺ | 550 ₺ |
| Unit contribution | 300 ₺ | 215 ₺ |
| Required sales increase | %39,5 |
Warning: if the campaign terms include extra commission, a participation fee or a mandatory discount share, read these items from the terms and add them to variable costs. To check commission rates by category, see the commission calculators.
Lesson 5: How do campaign expenses change the break-even point?
In short: Campaign-specific advertising, coupons, extra shipping and increased returns bring a burden independent of the discount. Dividing these expenses by the discounted unit contribution shows how many units they add, and the break-even threshold rises by that amount.
In the example, assume you spent ₺5,000 on advertising and extra packaging for the campaign. Normal contribution was ₺60,000. To break even, total contribution must be ₺65,000: 65,000 ÷ ₺200 = 325 units (300 units without expenses). The threshold rises from 50% to 62.5%.
- 33.3%effect of a 10% discount on unit profit
- 50%required sales increase (without commission)
- 39.5%required sales increase (with commission)
- 325 unitsbreak-even quantity when ₺5,000 in expenses is added
| Expenses | Effect | How is it factored in? |
|---|---|---|
| Advertising and promotion | Fixed amount | Deduct from total contribution |
| Coupon or basket discount | Additional discount | Add to the discount rate |
| Extra shipping and packaging | Grows with quantity | Add to variable costs |
| Increase in returns | Part of the sales come back | Reduce the net quantity by the expected return rate |
For the returns side, see the logic of the return invoice: returned units are deducted from campaign contribution.
Lesson 6: How is the stock and cash impact calculated?
In short: If the target quantity exceeds your stock, the discount has no benefit; if stock runs out, sales stop and the campaign advertising spend is wasted. Before the campaign, compare stock with the target quantity and the lead time.
- Set the target quantity: The break-even quantity and a realistic sales forecast.
- Compare with stock on hand: If stock is below the target, shorten the campaign or narrow its scope.
- Check the lead time: If no reorder will arrive during the campaign, all stock must be ready from the start.
- See the cash impact: Even if campaign contribution looks high, marketplace payouts are delayed; plan your cash flow.
To estimate the target quantity, see the articles how to forecast sales; for safety stock, how to calculate safety stock; and for the cash impact, how to calculate working capital. In NetKasam, you can set a critical stock level for your products and see stock movements and warehouse-level stock on a single screen (inventory management).
Lesson 7: Which products should be discounted?
In short: Discounts are given on products with a high margin, excess stock and sales that can genuinely increase with a discount. Discounting a low-margin product that already sells quickly is a loss of profit.
| Product situation | Discount decision | Why? |
|---|---|---|
| High margin, excess stock | OK | Required increase is low, stock is cleared |
| Low margin, fast-selling | Not suitable | Required increase is very high, it already sells |
| Slow-selling, aging stock | OK | Cash is freed up and warehouse cost falls; even if margin falls, cash is valuable |
| End-of-season product | OK | Waiting reduces its value |
| Complementary product pair | Discount on one product, full price on the other | The basket total generates contribution |
Classify products with ABC analysis (how to do an ABC analysis): fast-selling A-class products are rarely discounted, while slow C-class products get controlled discounts. For competitive pricing decisions, also see the article competitive pricing on marketplaces.
Lesson 8: How do you do post-campaign measurement and the checklist?
In short: After the campaign ends, calculate campaign contribution using the actual quantity, actual unit contribution and actual expenses, and compare it with the normal period. If the threshold wasn't met, the discount rate or scope changes in the next campaign.
| Scenario | Count | Discounted contribution (₺200) | Compared with normal contribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Period without discount | 200 | 60.000 ₺ (300 ₺ × 200) | Reference |
| Campaign, sales didn't increase | 200 | 40.000 ₺ | −20.000 ₺ |
| Campaign, 20% increase | 240 | 48.000 ₺ | −12.000 ₺ |
| Campaign, break-even | 300 | 60.000 ₺ | 0 |
| Campaign, 80% increase | 360 | 72.000 ₺ | +12.000 ₺ |
- Before the campaign: write down unit contribution, discount rate and break-even quantity.
- Add expenses: advertising, coupons, extra shipping, expected returns.
- Verify stock: target quantity and lead time.
- Monitor daily quantity during the campaign; if it stays below target, consider stopping.
- At the end of the campaign, calculate the real contribution and compare it with the normal period.
- Record the result: use it in the next campaign for the same product.
What are the most common mistakes in discounting without making a loss?
- Looking at revenue and not at profit. Revenue rises while contribution may fall.
- Applying the same discount to all products. Low-margin products cause losses.
- Not calculating contribution as an amount instead of a percentage. The unit profit amount shows what you lose with a discount.
- Not adding campaign expenses to the threshold. Advertising and extra shipping raise the break-even quantity.
- Starting a campaign without preparing stock. Stock runs out and sales stop.
- Ignoring the commission effect. If commission is a percentage, it falls with the price; otherwise the calculation comes out wrong.
- Not measuring results. A campaign that misses the threshold gets repeated the same way.
How do you track campaign profitability with NetKasam?
- Campaign module. You create campaigns by branch, warehouse, product, category or customer group, and report on and analyze them (inventory management).
- In-store campaigns. You can define campaigns specific to a product, category or store on special days or within certain date ranges (in-store POS screen).
- Customer-specific pricing. You can set risk limits and discounts on customer accounts (customer and supplier account tracking).
- Sales report. You save the campaign-period sales report, export it to Excel and paste it into your contribution table (reports).
- Critical stock. By setting a critical stock level for your product, you get an alert during the campaign before stock runs out.
- Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.
Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.
- If the price is ₺500 and the variable cost is ₺350, what are the unit contribution and contribution margin?
- If you apply a 10% discount to the same product, how many ₺ is the unit contribution, and by what percentage does it fall?
- If the contribution margin is 25% and the discount is 10%, what is the required sales increase?
- For a product that normally sells 100 units, what is the break-even quantity at this discount?
- If ₺3,000 in expenses is added for the campaign and the discounted unit contribution is ₺100, how many additional units are needed?
Answer key:
- 500 − 350 = 150 ₺; 150 ÷ 500 = %30.
- The price becomes ₺450; contribution is 450 − 350 = ₺100; it falls from ₺150 to ₺100, i.e. by about 33.3%.
- 0.10 ÷ (0.25 − 0.10) = 0.667, i.e. 66.7%.
- 100 × 0.25 ÷ 0.15 = 166.7, i.e. about 167 units.
- 3,000 ÷ 100 = 30 additional units.
Frequently Asked Questions About Discounting Without Making a Loss
How do you discount without making a loss?
Calculate unit contribution and contribution margin, find the break-even sales increase for the discount rate (d ÷ (m − d)), add campaign expenses and the commission effect, verify that stock covers the target quantity, and measure the real contribution at the end of the campaign.
How is the break-even sales increase calculated?
Discount rate divided by (contribution margin minus discount rate). If the contribution margin is 30% and the discount is 10%, the required increase is 0.10 ÷ 0.20 = 50%.
What is the contribution margin?
It is the ratio to the price of the amount left after variable costs (product, commission, shipping, packaging) are deducted from the sale price. In a discount decision, it shows how much of the price remains as profit.
At what margin does a discount make no sense?
If the discount rate is equal to or greater than the contribution margin, profit is zero or there is a loss on every sale. For example, a 30% discount cannot be given at a 30% margin.
How does commission affect a discount on a marketplace?
If commission is taken from the price as a percentage, it falls along with the discount and slightly protects unit contribution. Be sure to add any extra commission or participation fee in the campaign terms.
How are campaign expenses factored in?
Fixed expenses such as advertising are deducted from total contribution, coupons are added as an extra discount, and additional shipping as a variable cost. Expenses raise the break-even quantity.
Can I create campaigns in NetKasam?
Yes. You can create campaigns by branch, warehouse, product, category or customer group, and report on and analyze them. On the in-store POS screen, campaigns specific to special days and date ranges are defined.
What do you do if sales don't increase with the discount?
If you are below the target quantity, consider stopping the campaign or narrowing its scope. Record the result and change the rate and product selection in the next campaign.
Conclusion: write down the threshold before the campaign
A discount is a marketing tool, not a guarantee of profit. Before your next campaign, choose the product you are thinking of discounting the most, calculate its unit contribution and contribution margin, write down the break-even quantity for your discount rate and compare it with your stock. If the threshold is far above your target, lower the discount rate or choose another product.
Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free
Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.