How Do You Manage Cash on Delivery Orders? A Guide to Refusal Cost, the Break-Even Refusal Rate, the Decision to Switch to Card Payments, Pre-Shipment Confirmation and Collection Reconciliation
How do you manage cash-on-delivery orders? Rejection cost, breakeven rejection rate, switching to card payment, pre-shipment confirmation and reconciliation: an 8-lesson guide with examples.
Contents 14 sections
- What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
- Lesson 1: Why should cash on delivery be managed separately?
- Lesson 2: What is the contribution of delivered and rejected orders?
- Lesson 3: What are the monthly result and the breakeven rejection rate?
- Lesson 4: Is it profitable to turn off cash on delivery and steer customers to card payment?
- Lesson 5: How does a pre-shipment confirmation step lower the rejection rate?
- Lesson 6: How much does the cash-on-delivery collection delay cost, and how do you reconcile?
- Lesson 7: How do you set up the cash-on-delivery process?
- Lesson 8: How do you monitor cash on delivery?
- What are the most common mistakes in managing cash on delivery?
- How does NetKasam make cash-on-delivery management easier?
- Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
- Conclusion: Calculate this month's rejection rate and cost per rejection
- Frequently Asked Questions About Cash-on-Delivery Orders
Cash on delivery is an option that reassures customers and increases the number of orders. But not every cash-on-delivery order ends the same way: the courier goes to the door, the customer isn't home or says "I changed my mind", and the package goes back to the warehouse. You have paid for outbound shipping, return shipping and packing labor, and there isn't a single cent of sales to show for it. On top of that, the money for delivered orders arrives from the carrier days later.
This article is not a narrative but an 8-lesson practical training. We will answer the question how do you manage cash-on-delivery orders using an e-commerce business that receives 1,500 cash-on-delivery orders a month: the contribution of delivered and rejected orders, the breakeven rejection rate, when it is profitable to turn off cash on delivery and steer customers to card payment, the payoff of a pre-shipment confirmation step, the cost of collection delays, the reconciliation routine and monitoring indicators. At the end there is a mini quiz with an answer key. You can also find the impact of undelivered orders on the online sales side in the article how to sell online with product links; this article focuses on cash on delivery.
What will you be able to do by the end of this training?
In short: You will calculate the real contribution of a cash-on-delivery order, find the breakeven rejection rate, make the decision to turn it off with numbers, evaluate the confirmation step and track collections through reconciliation.
- 01ContributionFind the contribution of a delivered order.
- 02RejectionFind the cost of a rejected order.
- 03BreakevenCalculate the acceptable rejection rate.
- 04DecisionDecide whether to keep or turn off cash on delivery.
- 05ConfirmationEvaluate a pre-shipment confirmation step.
- 06CollectionMatch carrier payments with orders.
The training's 8 lessons: (1) how cash on delivery differs, (2) delivery and rejection contribution, (3) the monthly result and breakeven rejection rate, (4) the decision to turn it off, (5) pre-shipment confirmation, (6) collection delays and reconciliation, (7) implementation, (8) monitoring indicators.
Lesson 1: Why should cash on delivery be managed separately?
In short: With cash on delivery, payment is made at the moment of delivery; so if the customer doesn't accept the package, the sale doesn't happen and the shipping cost falls on you. With card payment, the money is collected in advance; with cash on delivery, afterward.
| Feature | Card payment | Cash on delivery |
|---|---|---|
| Payment timing | At the time of order | On delivery |
| Non-delivery risk | Low, payment already received | High, the customer may reject the package |
| Cost | Payment commission | Cash-on-delivery service fee, return shipping risk |
| When the money reaches you | Depends on the payment provider | Depends on the carrier's remittance period |
| Customer trust | Card details required | No payment until the package is seen; trust is high |
The advantage of cash on delivery is order conversion: customers who don't want to give card details or who are shopping for the first time place orders with this option. The disadvantage is two separate risks: non-acceptance and collection delay. Both can be managed with numbers.
Example business: 1,500 cash-on-delivery orders a month, average basket ₺400, product cost 60% of sales (₺240), shipping ₺55, packaging ₺10 and a cash-on-delivery service fee of ₺12 per order (example condition). Orders that aren't accepted go back into inventory, so the product cost isn't lost, but the outbound and return shipping and the packing labor are wasted. Of monthly orders, 12% are not accepted (180 orders).
Lesson 2: What is the contribution of delivered and rejected orders?
In short: A delivered order leaves a positive contribution once all costs are deducted from the sale. A rejected order posts a loss equal to outbound and return shipping plus packaging.
- Delivered order contribution = Basket − Product cost − Shipping − Packaging − Cash-on-delivery fee
- Rejected order cost = Outbound shipping + Return shipping + Packaging
- Breakeven rejection rate = Delivery contribution ÷ (Delivery contribution + Rejection cost)
Prepared with sample values.
| Order outcome | Account | Result per order |
|---|---|---|
| Delivered | 400 − 240 − 55 − 10 − 12 | +83 ₺ |
| Rejected | −(55 + 55 + 10) | −120 ₺ |
For a rejected order we don't count the product cost because the product goes back into inventory; if the product is damaged or has a short shelf life, the cost increases. The return shipping fee varies by carrier; use the return terms in your contract. To check shipping costs, see the article how to check a shipping invoice.
Lesson 3: What are the monthly result and the breakeven rejection rate?
In short: You find the monthly net contribution by multiplying the delivery and rejection results by the number of orders. The breakeven rejection rate is the rate at which the total contribution of cash-on-delivery orders is zero.
- Delivered₺1,32088%
- Rejected₺18012%
Prepared with sample values.
| Item | Order | Unit result | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delivered | 1.320 | +83 ₺ | 109.560 ₺ |
| Rejected | 180 | −120 ₺ | −21.600 ₺ |
| Net monthly contribution | 1.500 | – | 87.960 ₺ |
Check: 1,320 × 83 = ₺109,560; 180 × 120 = ₺21,600; difference ₺87,960, or ₺58.64 per order. With no rejections at all, 1,500 × 83 = ₺124,500 would have been earned; in other words, rejections create a monthly difference of ₺36,540: ₺21,600 in direct costs and ₺14,940 in lost contribution (180 × 83). That's why each rejected order costs ₺203 (83 + 120).
The breakeven rejection rate is 83 ÷ 203 = 40.9%: that is, even if 40.9% of orders are rejected, cash-on-delivery orders don't lose money overall. This rate shows cash on delivery's safety margin; the 12% in the example is well below breakeven. But calculate it separately for each product group: for low-margin products, the delivery contribution is small and the breakeven rejection rate drops quickly. To read margins correctly, see the article how to calculate profit margin, and to see return-related costs separately, how to calculate return cost.
Recommended readingHow Do You Calculate Return Cost?Lesson 4: Is it profitable to turn off cash on delivery and steer customers to card payment?
In short: Turning off cash on delivery eliminates rejection risk but loses some customers. The decision depends on whether the share of customers who will complete with a card exceeds the breakeven rate.
Order contribution with card payment: 400 − 240 − 8 (commission 2%) − 55 − 10 = ₺87. There is no rejection risk, but customers who don't want to give card details may abandon the order.
| Share completing with a card once cash on delivery is off | Order | Monthly contribution (at ₺87) | Vs. cash on delivery |
|---|---|---|---|
| %45 | 675 | 58.725 ₺ | −29.235 ₺ |
| %55 | 825 | 71.775 ₺ | −16.185 ₺ |
| 67.4% (breakeven) | ≈1.011 | ≈87.960 ₺ | ≈0 |
| %80 | 1.200 | 104.400 ₺ | +16.440 ₺ |
- Keep cash on delivery (12% rejection)₺87,960
- Turn it off, 55% complete with a card₺71,775
- Turn it off, 80% complete with a card₺104,400
Prepared with example values. Card order contribution ₺87, cash-on-delivery result ₺87,960.
Breakeven: 87,960 ÷ 87 ≈ 1,011 orders, that is, 67.4% of 1,500 orders. Cash-on-delivery customers are often the segment that prefers not to use cards; so a conversion of 55%-60 is more realistic, and at that point turning off cash on delivery posts a loss. Rather than turning it off, reducing the rejection rate is the better move. For the commission charged on card payments, see the article how to choose online collection methods.
Lesson 5: How does a pre-shipment confirmation step lower the rejection rate?
In short: Confirming with the customer by phone or message before handing the order to the carrier filters out customers who won't accept delivery before shipping. The gain is the avoided rejection cost; the price is the lost genuine orders and the confirmation cost.
Confirmation step example: of 1,500 orders, 80 cancel or can't be reached at the confirmation stage and aren't shipped. Of these, 72 are customers who would have rejected anyway, while 8 would have accepted delivery. The confirmation message or call costs ₺0.50 per order (example).
- Current monthly net contribution₺87,960
- Avoided cost of 72 rejections not shipped (72 × ₺120)₺8,640
- Loss of 8 genuine orders not confirmed (8 × ₺83)−₺664
- Confirmation cost (1,500 × ₺0.50)−₺750
- Monthly net contribution with the confirmation step₺95,186
Prepared with example values. Total: 87,960 + 8,640 − 664 − 750 = ₺95,186.
Net gain ₺7,226. Shipped orders total 1,420; rejections fall to 180 − 72 = 108, and the rejection rate becomes 108 ÷ 1,420 = 7.6%. Check: delivered 1,312 × 83 = ₺108,896, rejected 108 × 120 = ₺12,960, confirmation cost ₺750; 108,896 − 12,960 − 750 = ₺95,186. The payoff of the confirmation step depends on the share of customers who would reject: if it's high, it helps a lot; if it's low, it doesn't cover its cost. You can also lower the cost by applying confirmation only to risky orders, for example first-time buyers or high-value orders.
You can use your own communication channels for the confirmation step. For how to write order status notifications to customers, see the article how to send order updates to customers. To cancel an unconfirmed order, follow the flow in the article how to cancel an order.
Lesson 6: How much does a cash-on-delivery remittance delay cost, and how do you reconcile it?
In short: The carrier transfers the cash it collects at the door a few days later. This wait is a financing cost for you, and every transfer must be matched to orders.
If the transfer period is 7 days and the monthly financing cost is 4%, the waiting cost per delivered order is 400 × 0.04 × 7 ÷ 30 ≈ ₺3.73. For 1,320 delivered orders, that comes to ₺4,928 a month. Net contribution falls to 87,960 − 4,928 = ₺83,032. If the transfer period goes from 7 to 14 days, this cost rises to ₺9,856. That is why, in your agreement with the carrier, the transfer period matters as much as the price.
| Transfer period | Waiting cost per order | Monthly cost (1,320 orders) |
|---|---|---|
| 3 days | 1,60 ₺ | 2.112 ₺ |
| 7 days | 3,73 ₺ | 4.928 ₺ |
| 14 days | 7,47 ₺ | 9.856 ₺ |
Reconciliation means finding which orders each transfer belongs to. The carrier usually sends a list or statement; compare the amounts on it with your order totals. Differences come from three places: orders delivered but not transferred, orders transferred but not showing as delivered on your side, and amount differences. For the matching, you can use the method in the articles how to do a bank reconciliation and how to find and close account reconciliation differences. Tracking cash-on-delivery transfers in a current account opened for the carrier lets you see the open balance at any moment.
Lesson 7: How do you set up a cash-on-delivery process?
In short: Manage order statuses correctly, put refused orders back into inventory the same day, correct cancellation and return records, and track carrier transfers through customer and supplier accounts.
| Step | To do | Note |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Confirmation | For risky orders, confirm with the customer before shipping | Applying it to every order increases costs |
| 2. Shipping | Send the order to the carrier marked "cash on delivery" | The collection amount must match the order amount |
| 3. Refusal record | Update the status of the refused order | Put the product back into inventory the same day |
| 4. Invoice | If an invoice was issued for the refused order, run the return or cancellation flow | Confirm the accounting entry with your certified public accountant |
| 5. Transfer | Match carrier transfers to orders | Check the open balance weekly |
In NetKasam, you can track marketplace and e-commerce orders on a single screen, update their statuses, and cancel or partially cancel them when needed. Orders ready to ship are sent to the carrier through the shipping integration; with filters and bulk actions, you can process refused orders in one go. With the "Share" link on the product detail page, you can sell online with credit card or cash-on-delivery options. For details, see the pages order management, shipping integration and how to cancel an order. Record the return of refused products to inventory as described in the article how to find and close inventory discrepancies.
Lesson 8: How do you monitor cash on delivery?
In short: Track six indicators monthly: refusal rate, cost per refusal, break-even refusal rate, post-confirmation refusal rate, collection transfer period and open carrier balance.
| Indicator | Sample value | How it is calculated |
|---|---|---|
| Refusal rate | %12 | Refused ÷ Shipped (180 ÷ 1,500) |
| Total cost per refusal | 203 ₺ | Refusal cost + lost delivery contribution (120 + 83) |
| Break-even refusal rate | %40,9 | 83 ÷ 203 |
| Post-confirmation refusal rate | %7,6 | Refused ÷ Shipped (108 ÷ 1,420) |
| Transfer period | 7 days | Average days from delivery to cash receipt |
| Open carrier balance | From your own records | Amount delivered but not yet transferred |
- 40.9%the highest refusal rate at which cash-on-delivery orders do not lose money
- 67.4%the card completion rate needed for dropping cash on delivery to be profitable
- +₺7,226monthly net contribution of the confirmation step
- ₺4,928monthly cost of a 7-day transfer delay
If the refusal rate is rising, first look at the breakdown by product and region; refusals concentrated in a particular product group or city point to the solution. If the transfer period is getting longer, talk to the carrier. If the open balance is growing, reconciliation is behind. To read these indicators together with your other operational data, see the article how to prepare a weekly management report.
Recommended readingHow to Manage Orders in E-Commerce?What are the most common mistakes in managing cash on delivery?
- Looking only at delivered orders. The cost of refused orders goes uncounted.
- Tracking the refusal rate as a single number. Without a breakdown by product and region, you cannot find a solution.
- Dropping cash on delivery without doing the math. If the card completion rate falls below break-even, contribution drops.
- Confirming every order. For low-risk orders, the cost outweighs the gain.
- Not asking about the transfer period in the contract. The waiting cost stays invisible.
- Delaying reconciliation. Amounts delivered but not transferred get lost.
- Putting refused products back into inventory late. Inventory looks wrong and sales are missed.
How does NetKasam make cash-on-delivery management easier?
- Single-screen order management. You see orders together, update their statuses, and cancel or partially cancel them (order management).
- Shipping integration. Orders ready to ship are sent to the carrier automatically, and you can work with more than one carrier (shipping integration).
- Filters and bulk actions. You filter refused or pending-confirmation orders and update them in bulk.
- Online sales with cash on delivery. With the "Share" link on the product detail page, you sell with credit card or cash-on-delivery options (online sales).
- Account and bank tracking. You track carrier transfers in a current account and match them with bank transactions (customer and supplier account tracking).
- Saved reports. You save the refusal and delivery report, export it to Excel and track the indicators in your own spreadsheet (reports).
- Bookkeeping is free. e-Invoice, customer and supplier accounts, inventory, cash, bank and expense management are free in every plan; see the pricing page for details.
Mini quiz: Test what you have learned
In short: Answer the 5 questions below, then compare with the answer key. 4 or 5 correct shows you have completed the training.
- If the basket is ₺300, product cost is 60%, shipping is ₺50, packaging is ₺10 and the cash-on-delivery fee is ₺10, what is the contribution of a delivered order?
- If outbound shipping is ₺50, return shipping is ₺50 and packaging is ₺10, what is the cost of a refused order?
- What is this business's break-even refusal rate?
- With 1,000 orders and a 10% refusal rate, what is the monthly net contribution?
- For a ₺300 order, if the monthly financing cost is 3% and the transfer period is 10 days, what is the waiting cost?
Answer key:
- 300 − 180 − 50 − 10 − 10 = 50 ₺.
- 50 + 50 + 10 = 110 ₺.
- 50 ÷ (50 + 110) = %31,25.
- Delivered 900 × 50 = ₺45,000; refused 100 × 110 = ₺11,000; net ₺34,000.
- 300 × 0,03 × 10 ÷ 30 = 3 ₺.
Frequently Asked Questions About Cash-on-Delivery Orders
How do you manage cash-on-delivery orders?
You calculate the contribution of delivered and rejected orders separately, track the rejection rate, get confirmation before shipping risky orders and match carrier remittances with orders.
What does an undelivered cash-on-delivery order cost?
Outbound shipping, return shipping and packing labor; if the product goes back into inventory, the product cost isn't lost. On top of that, the contribution expected from that order is also lost.
How do you calculate the breakeven rejection rate?
You divide the contribution of a delivered order by the sum of the delivery contribution and the rejection cost. At rejection rates below this level, cash-on-delivery orders are profitable overall.
Should I turn off cash on delivery?
Yes, if the share of customers who complete with a card after you turn it off exceeds the breakeven rate. In the example this rate is 67.4%; for most businesses the realistic rate is lower.
Does getting confirmation before shipping help?
Yes, if the share of customers who will reject is high. The confirmation cost is assessed by deducting it, along with lost genuine orders, from the avoided cost of rejections that are never shipped.
When does cash-on-delivery money arrive?
It depends on the carrier's remittance period. This period is stated in your contract; a long period creates a financing cost.
How do I reconcile carrier remittances?
You match the amounts on the carrier's statement with order totals and list delivered-but-not-remitted orders and amount differences separately.
How does NetKasam help with cash-on-delivery management?
It manages orders on one screen and offers shipping integration, filters and bulk actions, account and bank tracking and saved reports; you can sell with cash on delivery via product links; bookkeeping is free.
Conclusion: Calculate this month's refusal rate and cost per refusal
The most useful thing you can do today is split last month's cash-on-delivery orders into delivered and refused and find two numbers: the refusal rate and the total cost per refusal. Then divide your delivery contribution by that cost to calculate your break-even refusal rate. The gap between them shows how safe cash on delivery is for you; if the gap is narrow, try the confirmation step first and consider dropping cash on delivery only as a last resort.
Bookkeeping Is Now Completely Free
Manage your bookkeeping and e-Invoice operations with NetKasam without paying a thing. Customer and supplier accounts, inventory, collections and more in one panel, completely free.